Sliced tri-tip smoked like brisket, showing the rendered fat and smoke ring

Tri-Tip Smoked Like Brisket: Roel’s Trisket Test

Roel Westra

A full brisket makes sense when you are feeding a crowd. For a family meal, Roel wants the same soft, smoky beef without a week of leftovers. His answer is a beautifully marbled tri-tip, cooked like brisket on the Napoleon Apollo 22. The result earns its nickname: trisket.

What is trisket? It is tri-tip smoked and finished in the style of brisket. In Roel’s test, a 1.2–1.3 kg cut becomes tender, juicy beef after about 4½ hours of cooking and a further 2-hour rest. The unusually rich marbling is central to this result.

Why this particular tri-tip is worth smoking like brisket

The beef comes from a neighbour’s Holstein–Black Angus cross, butchered locally with Van der Horst. Roel is struck by the fat running through the meat: it reminds him of Wagyu, although this is not Wagyu beef.

Raw, heavily marbled tri-tip on a rack before smoking
The rich marbling is the reason Roel chooses this tri-tip for a brisket-style cook.

That distinction matters more than the nickname. This is a test with an exceptionally well-marbled piece of meat, weighing about 1.2–1.3 kg / 2.6–2.9 lb. Roel’s enthusiasm at the end is tied to that starting point. A much leaner tri-tip is not the same proposition, and this episode does not establish that every tri-tip will turn out equally succulent.

The appeal is its scale. Roel is looking for brisket-style eating in a smaller cut that suits his family, rather than a replacement for every large brisket cook.

A smaller cut gives you less time to build bark

Roel’s main challenge is balancing the outside with the inside. A large brisket has a long cooking window in which to develop its bark and smoke flavour. This smaller piece can warm through before the outside reaches the same point.

He chooses the Napoleon Apollo 22 for its vertical charcoal-smoker setup and the smoke profile he enjoys. He describes that profile as reminiscent of an offset smoker; that is his reason for choosing it, rather than a claim that the two smokers are identical.

Roel setting up the Napoleon Apollo 22 charcoal smoker
Roel prepares the Apollo 22 for a gentle charcoal smoke.

His Minion-style setup starts the briquettes burning in the centre, with two chunks of smoking wood. The smoker settles around 120°C / 248°F. The video does not identify the wood species, so the useful detail here is the controlled, gentle start.

Why the fat cap faces the fire

Roel places the scored fat cap towards the heat source, with the meat side above it. He uses that layer as a shield against radiant heat while the beef cooks. He is not searing the fat cap first: it goes into the smoker as part of the low-and-slow stage.

After roughly 1½ hours, the surface has taken on colour. Roel could keep chasing a more pronounced bark, but chooses to move on. For this small, delicate cut, a heavier exterior is not his only measure of success.

The wrap changes the focus from bark to tenderness

At the end of that initial smoke, Roel inserts a wireless ChefsTemp ProTemp 2 Plus probe into the centre. Tracking the rise matters because a small cut can move through the next stage quickly.

Roel with the smoked tri-tip and ChefsTemp ProTemp 2 Plus base
After the initial smoke, Roel uses the wireless probe to follow the centre temperature.

He spreads a little melted beef tallow over butcher paper, places the beef on it with the fat cap still down, and wraps it snugly. The tallow wets the paper to begin with; he expects the meat to release more fat and juices during the wrapped stage.

Roel spreading melted beef tallow on butcher paper before wrapping
A little melted beef tallow goes onto the butcher paper before wrapping.

His priority now is giving the beef time to soften. Reaching a number quickly is not the same as getting the texture he wants. He watches the temperature while allowing the wrapped cook to do its work, rather than treating the initial smoking time as the whole process.

4½ hours cooking, then 2 hours resting

Roel removes this trisket at an internal temperature of 94°C / 201°F, then holds it wrapped in a cooler for approximately 2 hours. When he totals up the cook, the stages are:

  • About 1½ hours: initial unwrapped smoke.
  • About 3 hours: wrapped cooking.
  • About 2 hours: resting in the cooler.

That is roughly 6½ hours from the start of smoking to slicing, including the rest. These are the timings of Roel’s filmed cook, not a guarantee for a different cut or smoker setup.

The verdict: brisket-like texture in a family-sized cut

After the rest, the beef is very soft while still holding together for slicing. Roel finds a visible smoke ring, rendered fat and plenty of juice. His tasting verdict centres on the delicate texture: it breaks apart easily, tastes beefy and carries smoke without becoming overpowering.

The whole smoked tri-tip unwrapped after its two-hour rest
The trisket after its wrapped cook and two-hour rest, ready to slice.

He is particularly happy with the moment he chose to wrap. The finished result supports his decision to stop building the bark and give the smaller piece a gentler finish.

Is tri-tip better than brisket?

For the job Roel set himself—smoky, tender beef for a smaller meal—this trisket works very well. It is easier to fit that quantity into a family dinner, and he is pleased with the time it takes.

The episode is not a side-by-side test of a brisket and a tri-tip cooked under identical conditions. It demonstrates what this well-marbled tri-tip can do. The most useful takeaway is to choose the meat carefully, account for its smaller size and judge the finish by the texture as well as the temperature.

Equipment used in this cook

Main sponsor

Napoleon Apollo 22

The vertical charcoal smoker used for this trisket. Roel combines a centre-lit briquette setup with smoking wood and places the fat cap towards the fire for the initial smoke.

Explore the Napoleon Apollo 22

Wireless temperature monitoring

ChefsTemp ProTemp 2 Plus

The wireless thermometer setup shown in the video. Monitoring the centre helps Roel follow the temperature rise during the wrapped stage, without relying on elapsed time alone.

Current partner offer: use code PITMASTERX for 25% off in the ChefsTemp shop.

Shop the ProTemp 2 Plus

Napoleon is the main sponsor of this video. ChefsTemp also supports PitmasterX; the equipment links above are partner links.

Watch the trisket test

Original PitmasterX video: Is this Mini version better than the American BBQ Brisket · Published 25 June 2026.

Tested by Roel Westra

Roel is the cook behind PitmasterX. This article draws on his filmed trisket cook, its transcript and original frames from the video. The timings and tasting observations describe that cook.

For another look at how beef responds to heat, read Roel’s test of Guga’s crust-first steak method or explore the smoked oxtail tacos recipe.

Powrót do blogu