Sliced steak from Roel's test of Guga's method, showing a browned crust and pink interior

Guga’s Steak Method Tested: Crust First vs Reverse Sear

Roel Westra

Guga’s steaks have the kind of crust that makes you stop scrolling. Roel follows the method from Guga’s tutorial on his own Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle: build the crust first, baste with seasoned butter, then finish away from the coals. The result tastes excellent. The difficult part is getting an already-hot kettle to slow down.

What is different about this steak method? The first stage prioritises the crust, using intense charcoal heat, frequent turning and cooler sections of the grate. The centre is finished afterwards. Reverse sear uses the opposite order: gentle cooking first, then the final sear.

PitmasterX Beef Seasoning used in the butter for Roel's steak test
The Beef seasoning Roel mixes into his basting butter.

Two heat zones make the method possible

Roel concentrates the charcoal and briquettes on one side of the Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle, leaving the other side without fuel directly beneath it. One side supplies intense direct heat; the other gives him somewhere to move the steak when the fire becomes too aggressive.

Roel's divided Napoleon Kettle Pro charcoal setup with separate direct and indirect sides
Roel separates the fuel side from the side used for indirect cooking and brief pauses.

That second zone is useful throughout the cook, not just at the end. Roel moves the steak away from the coals to apply butter and to step back from flare-ups. The setup gives him room to react instead of leaving the steak over one fixed heat source.

The steak is thick and elongated, with several exposed faces to brown. Roel works on those surfaces rather than treating it as a flat steak that only needs one flip.

A hot fire, but cooler grate contact

Roel’s kettle has cast-iron grates. He puts them in after the charcoal has heated up, so they are still cool when the steak first goes on. He then follows Guga’s approach of rotating the grate and turning the meat, bringing a cooler section of grate into use.

The aim is a browned crust without letting one contact point scorch. A grate section does heat up once it is over the fire; rotating it is an active way of managing that contact heat, rather than a way to keep the whole grate cold.

Roel lifting the steak above the charcoal to show the developed brown crust
The crust is the priority in the first stage, with repeated turning and repositioning.

The phrase “crust first” describes the priority. The centre is already warming during this stage, but Roel is concentrating on the outside: turning, moving and checking the colour instead of holding the steak still for grill marks.

What the butter adds

The seasoned butter brings another layer of flavour to the surface. Roel brushes it on with the steak away from the direct fire, then keeps moving the meat as the cook progresses. When flames grow, he moves the steak to the cooler side or lifts it off.

The basting is part of the method he particularly enjoys. It also adds another task to an already active cook: controlling the fire, rotating the grate and watching the crust all happen together.

Crust first versus reverse sear

Crust first: the method tested here

Start with the intense heat needed to build the outside, then finish the centre gently. The challenge Roel encounters is reducing the heat after loading the kettle with enough fuel for that first stage.

Reverse sear: the order is reversed

Bring the steak towards its intended internal temperature gently, then finish with the sear. As Roel points out, this avoids having to cool an already very hot barbecue before the gentle stage.

This episode tests the crust-first method. Roel’s comparison with reverse sear explains the difference in heat management; it is not a side-by-side cook of two identical steaks.

The hot-kettle problem

For the finish, Roel wants an indirect cooking environment of around 120°C / 248°F. Getting there proves difficult. The fuel and the barbecue remain hot, and he reports spending about half an hour trying to bring the temperature down.

He notices pauses in the tutorial and adapts by taking the steak off periodically, checking it and returning it to the grill. Those pauses become a way to slow the finish when the kettle will not cool as quickly as he wants.

Roel’s 52°C target and the thermometer checks

Roel chooses a core-temperature target of 52°C / 126°F for his steak. He uses the ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10 to check progress rather than judging the centre from the crust alone.

Roel checking his steak with the ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10 on the Napoleon Kettle Pro
Roel checks the steak as he manages the finish on the kettle.

He measures in the centre and then slowly withdraws the probe to see how the reading changes through the meat. That gives him more information than a single reading at one depth. Combined with the off-grill pauses, it helps him decide when to keep cooking and when to give the steak time.

He also uses temperature checks during the rest. The point in this test is to watch how the steak is changing, rather than assign a fixed resting time regardless of its thickness or how much heat it has taken on.

The result: excellent crust, active cooking

When Roel cuts into the steak, it has a developed brown crust and a pink centre. He enjoys the juicy texture and the butter flavour. The finished steak is a success in his tasting.

Roel holding both halves of the cooked steak to show its centre and crust
The cut-open steak from Roel’s test: a browned exterior and a pink centre.

His qualification is just as useful as the result: Guga makes the process look easier than Roel finds it in practice. The turning, grate rotation, flare-up control and temperature checks demand attention. Roel recommends learning reverse sear first, then trying this more hands-on approach.

The lesson is to judge both stages separately. Getting the outside where you want it does not mean the centre is ready, and building a strong fire does not mean it will immediately settle down for a gentle finish.

Equipment used in this test

Main sponsor

Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle

The charcoal kettle used by Roel, with cast-iron cooking grates. In this test, the split fuel setup gives him direct and indirect zones, while rotating the grate lets him change the surface touching the steak.

Explore the Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle

Temperature checks

ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10

The instant-read thermometer used for Roel’s core checks and probe-withdrawal technique. A quick reading is useful here because he repeatedly checks the steak between short periods on and off the grill.

Use code PITMASTERX for 25% off in the ChefsTemp shop.

Shop the Finaltouch X10

Napoleon is the main sponsor of this video. ChefsTemp also supports PitmasterX; the equipment links above are partner links.

Watch Roel test Guga’s method

Original PitmasterX video: I tried Guga’s Steak method · Published 4 July 2026. Roel follows and comments on Guga’s tutorial within the video.

Tested by Roel Westra

Roel is the cook behind PitmasterX. This article is based on his filmed test, the video transcript and original PitmasterX cooking frames. Guga is credited for the method being tested; the observations and tasting verdict are Roel’s.

Explore another route to a steak crust in our cast-iron skillet test, or see how cut and tenderness compare in our ribeye cap versus ribeye test.

Powrót do blogu