Roel holds the new X002 by its two short handles as a fried egg slides across the pan.

Can a new cast iron skillet release an egg? The X001 and X002 egg test

Roel Westra — PitmasterX
Roel holds the new X002 by its two short handles as a fried egg slides across the pan.
Roel holds the new X002 by its two short handles as a fried egg slides across the pan.

I wanted to keep a full 12-inch cooking surface and still get the pan into an oven or the middle of a barbecue without a long handle in the way. Viewers had asked for that too. That’s where the X002 came from. To give it a first run, I set my well-used X001 next to it, put butter on the counter and cracked two eggs.

See the X002 with two handles

What two short handles change

The X001 has a long handle and a small helper handle. The X002 has a short grip on either side. It takes up less room around the cooking surface, handy when a grill lid or an oven door has to close. Both are hand-polished cast iron. My original pan had already seen a year and a half of cooking on the stove, on the barbecue, over open fire and in the oven. The cooking surface had darkened, but I could still see the polish when I tilted it.

The first egg in my everyday X001

I give the pan about a minute on my little gas stove. I want the butter to melt as it hits the surface. In goes the egg. After roughly 30 seconds, I move the pan gently. The egg slides, so I give it a flip. The underside is just lightly golden. That movement tells me more about when to turn it than the clock does.

An egg cooks in melted butter in the darker X001 skillet.
An egg cooks in melted butter in the darker X001 skillet.

The first cook in the X002

I keep the burner at the same setting and warm the new pan. This time I wipe the first bit of melted butter across the polished surface with a paper towel, then add fresh butter and the second egg. I wait until I can see bubbles underneath the whole egg before giving the pan a swirl. It slides on the first cook. Both eggs had butter. The useful cue in either pan was the moment the egg started moving freely.

A fresh piece of butter melts on the polished surface of the X002.
A fresh piece of butter melts on the polished surface of the X002.

After the test

I turn off the gas and wipe out the remaining butter with a paper towel. For a wash, I use water and a little dish soap, then dry the cast iron thoroughly. I also talk about tomato paste in the video. The food I actually cooked in this comparison was an egg in each pan. For me, the choice comes down to where I cook and which handle I want to grab.

Roel wipes the inside of the X002 with a paper towel after frying the egg.
Roel wipes the inside of the X002 with a paper towel after frying the egg.

Equipment

Read my six-month skillet test

Watch the egg test

Watch the egg test · YouTube

Video chapters
Back to blog