Top view of two cast iron skillets, with the shiny new pan on the left and the darker, seasoned pan on the right.

Hand-polished cast iron: a new skillet versus six months of cooking

Roel Westra — PitmasterX
Top view of two cast iron skillets, with the shiny new pan on the left and the darker, seasoned pan on the right.
Same 12-inch skillet, two stages of use. The pan on the left is new. Roel has cooked with the one on the right for six months.

My everyday skillet has gone dark. The one I’ve just unboxed still shines like a mirror. Both are the same 12-inch pan. An egg and two steaks show what that colour change tells you, and what you can already do on day one.

See the 12-inch skillet

What six months of cooking changes

I developed this skillet with The Windmill. The cooking surface is polished by hand. Put the two pans side by side and the one that’s been on my stove for six months is easy to spot. Regular cooking has darkened the surface into a patina. Run a hand over it and it still feels smooth. I didn’t put it through a separate, heavy seasoning routine for this test.

The egg test starts with a film of oil

I warm the used pan, add a little oil and spread it with a paper towel. The egg goes in while the pan is warm enough to cook it gently. Once the white has set, a small movement of the pan sends the egg sliding. When I lift it, you can see the golden underside. Watch that moment before deciding how much oil an egg needs.

The underside of the egg after frying in a thin film of oil.
The underside of the egg after frying in a thin film of oil.

First steak: let the fat do its work

In the used skillet I add the steak without pouring in more oil. I press it down for contact, then ease the heat back and give the fat time to render. After a few minutes I turn it. The browned surface shows where the meat was touching the iron.

Roel lifts the steak to show the crust from the well-used skillet.
Roel lifts the steak to show the crust from the well-used skillet.

Second steak: straight into the cold, new pan

This time the steak goes into the shiny pan straight from the box. The first thing you hear is silence. As the iron heats up, the meat starts to sizzle and its fat renders. I press it flat, then lift it to show the crust developing. Both pans released their steaks in this cook. The cold start is what makes the second test worth watching.

The second steak comes out of the new skillet after a cold start.
The second steak comes out of the new skillet after a cold start.

See the bone-in ribeye crust test

How I clean the skillet after cooking

I wipe out the fat, loosen anything stuck with a little water and dry the pan on both sides. In the video I also discuss tomato sauce: it can lighten the patina. In that case I rinse, dry and wipe on a thin film of oil. The silver finish is a starting point. The darker pan is the one I reach for every day.

Equipment

12-inch hand-polished cast iron skillet, cooking oil and paper towel.

See the 12-inch skillet

Watch the original video

Watch the original video · YouTube

Video chapters
Back to blog