Three grilled ribeye alternatives on the cutting board: chuck steak, bavette and hanger steak.

3 Ribeye Alternatives: Chuck, Bavette and Hanger Steak

Roel Westra

A good steak does not have to be a ribeye. In this charcoal-grill comparison, Roel puts chuck steak, bavette and hanger steak to the test. He looks at flavour, tenderness, the fat left on the plate and what makes each cut worth buying.

Roel’s pick: hanger steak. It wins him over with its flavour and value. Chuck is his familiar, marbled alternative, while bavette rewards careful slicing. For all three, choosing the right cut and cutting it well matter just as much as building a good crust.

Texas seasoning for a charcoal crust

Roel seasons the bavette with PitmasterX Texas Seasoning on both sides before grilling it over direct heat. It is the seasoning named in this video.

Shop Texas Seasoning

Why look beyond ribeye?

Roel still loves ribeye, particularly the cap and its rich flavour. His question is whether it always gives you the best value. A thin pre-packed steak can look inexpensive until you compare its price per kilogram or pound. And if you leave the larger pieces of fat on your plate, part of what you bought goes uneaten.

That gives him a clear brief: find steaks with plenty of flavour, enjoyable tenderness and less waste. Price matters too, but local butcher prices decide whether an alternative actually saves you money.

Roel presents a large alternative steak during the ribeye comparison.
Roel looks beyond ribeye for a different balance of flavour, texture and value.

1. Chuck steak: ask for the ribeye end

The first alternative comes with an important detail. Roel wants the steak from the end of the chuck closest to the ribeye. A random slice from a chuck roast will not necessarily behave the same way on the grill, so explain the cut you are looking for to your butcher.

He likes this steak for its rich beef flavour and marbling. In the tasting, its relatively fine structure also makes it more forgiving to slice than the bavette. It is still not as tender as ribeye, and there is some fat between the muscles.

If avoiding that fat is your main reason for moving away from ribeye, chuck may not solve the problem. If you enjoy it and want a flavourful grilling steak, the right end of the chuck is worth a look.

2. Bavette: big flavour, visible grain

The second steak is the bavette, referred to as “flap meat” in the video. Roel’s piece has a pronounced grain: long fibres run through the meat in a clear direction. Those fibres are the key to how you should slice it.

He likes its strong flavour and the relatively clean piece of meat, with little to leave behind on the plate. It is thinner than the other steaks in this cook, so he focuses on grilling it over direct heat and developing the crust.

The trade-off is that bavette can be very chewy when sliced along the grain. It can also cost more than you expect. In Roel’s comparison, its increasing popularity has reduced the price advantage over ribeye.

3. Hanger steak: Roel’s favourite

Hanger steak is the cut Roel is most excited about. Its irregular shape is less familiar than a neat ribeye, but the flavour and the final bite make it his favourite of the three.

He describes it as a butcher’s steak: a cut valued for eating quality rather than tidy presentation. As with bavette, the direction of the grain matters when slicing. In this tasting, Roel finds the hanger steak more tender than the bavette and especially appealing for the price.

Roel holds a grilled hanger steak beside the other cuts in the comparison.
Hanger steak is Roel’s favourite in this comparison.
How the three steaks compare in Roel’s test
Cut Why choose it? What to watch
Chuck steak Marbling, rich flavour and a relatively fine structure. Ask for the ribeye end; some fat remains between the muscles.
Bavette Strong beef flavour and little waste on the plate. Slice thinly across the grain and check the local price.
Hanger steak Roel’s favourite for flavour and value in this comparison. Expect an irregular shape and pay attention to the grain.

Grilling on the Napoleon Kettle Grill

The Napoleon Kettle Grill provides the charcoal heat for this comparison. For the thinner bavette, Roel concentrates on the direct zone, allowing the outside to develop a crust without treating it like a thick roast.

At the slicing stage, he reports a core temperature of 54°C / 129°F for the grilled and rested steaks. That is the result shown in this cook, rather than a fixed number of minutes to apply to every cut.

For quick core-temperature checks as you grill, the ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10 is the instant-read option featured alongside this article. Check the centre of the steak so you can judge the interior as well as the crust.

The knife makes a difference

Before slicing bavette or hanger steak, look for the direction of the muscle fibres. Turn the meat so your knife cuts across those fibres, then make thin slices. You shorten the fibres in each bite instead of leaving long strands to chew through.

Roel slices the grilled steaks on the cutting board.
Look at the direction of the fibres before cutting thin slices across the grain.

Roel demonstrates this particularly clearly with the bavette. Once cut across the grain, a slice pulls apart easily in his hands. The chuck is more forgiving, but the bavette makes a poor cutting angle immediately obvious.

Which ribeye alternative would we choose?

Roel’s winner is hanger steak. He loves its flavour, likes the tenderness and considers it good value in this comparison. Chuck is a strong option when you want marbling and a familiar steak experience. Bavette earns its place for flavour, provided you slice it carefully and the price makes sense where you shop.

Roel tastes a slice of steak during the three-cut comparison.
Roel tastes each steak to compare flavour and texture.

The useful takeaway is to buy for the eating experience you enjoy. If you dislike large seams of fat, factor that into your choice. If you like a strong beef flavour and do not mind learning how to slice a different cut, there is plenty to explore beyond ribeye.

This comparison was filmed for the video published on 23 April 2026. The video’s “under $20” title is not a current price guarantee; prices depend on location, portion size and supplier.

Want to explore the ribeye itself? Read our ribeye cap versus ribeye charcoal test.

Watch the three-steak comparison

Equipment and seasoning

Napoleon Kettle Grill

The charcoal barbecue used for this steak comparison. Napoleon is the main sponsor of this PitmasterX video.

Explore Napoleon Kettle Grills

ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10

An instant-read thermometer for checking core temperature while you grill.

Use code PITMASTERX for 25% off in the ChefsTemp shop.

Shop the Finaltouch X10

PitmasterX Texas Seasoning

The seasoning Roel applies to both sides of the bavette before direct grilling.

Shop Texas Seasoning

Napoleon is the main sponsor and ChefsTemp is our thermometer partner. The equipment links are sponsor links. Texas Seasoning is our own PitmasterX product.

By Roel Westra, PitmasterX. Based on the video originally published on 23 April 2026.

Tillbaka till blogg