A slice of the grilled spider steak showing its pink centre and browned crust

Spider Steak: The Cut, the Crust and Our Tasting Verdict

Roel Westra

After 15 years of cooking steaks, a butcher still had a surprise for Roel: spider steak. It is small, flat and marked with a web of fat. He takes it home, grills it over charcoal in the Napoleon Prestige PRO 665, and brings out familiar steaks to see whether the discovery deserves a place among his favourites.

Is spider steak a hidden alternative to ribeye?

Roel enjoys its beef flavour and crust, but finds this piece noticeably chewy. His verdict: an interesting butcher's cut worth trying, especially if it is being saved during butchery, but it does not become his new favourite steak.

What is spider steak?

Spider steak is a small cut taken from the inside of the hip, close to the aitch bone. There are just two per animal. Its web-like marbling explains the spider name; the flat shape is immediately visible when Roel lays it on a rack.

Raw spider steak showing its flat shape and web-like marbling
The raw spider steak is flat, with a distinctive web of fat running through the meat.

You may also encounter the names oyster steak or the French araignée. Roel refers to the Dutch spinnenkop too. Names vary between butchers: Swaledale's description of the cut notes that “Pope's Eye” can mean different things in different places. Describing the hip-bone location is more useful than relying on a nickname alone.

Why it is easy to miss at the butcher

Roel discovers the cut during a butcher visit. He is told there is too little of it on each animal for that butcher's usual restaurant sales, so it would otherwise go with the trimmings.

That is what interests him: it is a steak he has not tried, hiding inside a carcass being broken down for other cuts. The story explains why he wants to taste it. Scarcity by itself does not tell him whether the meat will be tender.

A thin steak needs attention to both crust and centre

Roel adds a little olive oil and Texas Seasoning, then lets the meat stand for about 10 minutes while he prepares the grill. He wants a browned exterior without keeping this relatively flat steak over the heat longer than necessary.

The challenge he describes is balancing colour on the outside with the doneness inside. A deeply browned crust is only one part of a good result. That is why he keeps returning to the core-temperature check with the ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10, aiming for medium rare in this cook.

Using the Napoleon with a charcoal insert

The barbecue is the Napoleon Prestige PRO 665, but the steak is cooked over charcoal. Roel removes part of the cooking grids and sear plates, installs a charcoal tray and uses the gas burners to light the coals. Once the charcoal is established, he turns the gas off.

Glowing charcoal beneath the cooking grate inside the Napoleon gas grill
The gas grill becomes the housing for a charcoal cook, with lit coals beneath the grate.

This uses a dedicated charcoal insert. For a compatible Napoleon setup, see the manufacturer's Cast Iron Charcoal and Smoker Tray and its fitting instructions. The relevant technique is gas-assisted ignition followed by cooking over the coals.

Spider steak searing over charcoal in the Napoleon Prestige PRO 665
Roel develops the crust over charcoal while keeping an eye on the thin steak's centre.

He rests the steak before slicing. The video does not give a fixed grilling time to apply to every spider steak; its shape and the fire in front of you are part of the judgement.

Finding the grain is part of the job

At the cutting board, Roel encounters the difficult part of this particular piece: the muscle fibres appear to run in several directions. He also finds some tendon. A single slicing direction does not neatly work across the whole cut.

Roel slicing the rested spider steak while checking the direction of the grain
Roel checks the fibre direction as he slices the rested spider steak.

He tries to cut thinly across the grain. The practical lesson is to inspect each section and turn the meat as the direction changes. “Against the grain” describes a relationship to the fibres, not one fixed angle to the cutting board.

Slicing deserves attention here, but the tasting still has to answer whether the texture is enjoyable. The presence of fat and an attractive crust do not make every part of this steak equally easy to chew.

Spider steak versus the familiar favourites

The first bite gives Roel two clear impressions. He loves the flavour and is pleased with the crust. Tenderness is the reservation. He compares the chew with tougher cuts, rather than describing the soft bite he had hoped to discover.

He then grills a ribeye, bife de tira and flap meat as reference steaks. In his explanation, the bife de tira is a strip-loin steak cut in a different direction. All three are shown in the comparison sequence after cooking and resting.

Video comparison of bife de tira, ribeye and flap meat as reference steaks
Bife de tira, ribeye and flap meat provide familiar reference points for the tasting.
What Roel finds in the spider steak
Aspect Observation from this cook
Flavour Enjoyable, pronounced beef flavour.
Crust A well-browned exterior he is happy with.
Tenderness Chewier than he wants from a favourite steak, with some tendon in this piece.
Overall verdict A worthwhile discovery for an enthusiast, rather than a new steak to replace his favourites.

This is a personal tasting of the cuts shown, not a scored blind ranking. The useful result is Roel's distinction between flavour and tenderness: he can enjoy the spider steak without deciding it is better than the steaks he already knows.

Would he buy or cook it again?

Roel's enthusiasm is strongest for saving it during butchery. If a carcass is already being broken down, he likes the idea of keeping the spider steaks separate, packing them and cooking one occasionally.

His conclusion sets the right expectation for a first try. Look forward to an interesting cut with character; do not assume an unfamiliar name means you have found a more tender ribeye. The piece in this video delivers flavour and a good crust, with a firmer bite.

Equipment and partner links

Main sponsor

Napoleon Prestige PRO 665

The grill used for this tasting, with a charcoal insert and the gas burners switched off once the coals are lit.

View the Prestige PRO 665 at Napoleon
Core-temperature checks

ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10

Roel uses this instant-read thermometer to follow the centre of a thin steak while developing its crust. The rotating probe helps you reach the right angle without relying on surface colour alone.

Use code PITMASTERX for 25% off at ChefsTemp.

Shop the Finaltouch X10

Charcoal accessory: see Napoleon’s Cast Iron Charcoal and Smoker Tray for the manufacturer’s compatible insert and fitting instructions.

Questions about spider steak

Where does spider steak come from?

It is a small cut from inside the hip, close to the aitch bone. There are two per animal.

Is spider steak always tender?

Roel's piece in this test is chewy despite an enjoyable flavour and crust. His experience does not support buying it solely as a tenderness upgrade.

Was it cooked with gas or charcoal?

The grill is a Napoleon Prestige PRO 665. Roel uses gas to ignite charcoal in an insert, turns the burners off, and cooks the steak over the coals.

How does he slice it?

Thinly, trying to cut across the fibres. Because the grain changes direction, he has to check the different parts of the steak as he goes.

Watch the full video

Watch on YouTube

  1. 00:00 — Discovering a new steak
  2. 01:42 — What spider steak looks like
  3. 02:15 — Oil and Texas Seasoning
  4. 02:48 — The charcoal insert
  5. 03:11 — Grilling and temperature checks
  6. 03:50 — Finding the grain
  7. 04:24 — First tasting
  8. 04:54 — The reference steaks
  9. 05:25 — Final verdict
Roel Westra · PitmasterX

Based on Roel's original spider-steak discovery and tasting. The photographs are original frames from the video.

See the same barbecue used differently in our gas-grill ribs guide, or explore another beef comparison: dry-aged versus wet-aged ribeye.

Tillbaka till blogg