Sliced pan-cooked steak coated with fresh herbs and dressing on the board

Seasoned-Board Steak: Testing the Viral Jordan Stallion Hack

Roel Westra

Cook a steak without seasoning it, then slice it on a board covered with fresh herbs, garlic and lemon. That is the viral method Roel tests after seeing Jordan the Stallion try it. He enjoys the first result, then takes the same board-dressing idea to the Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle for a version with smoke, char and a gentler balance of garlic and lemon.

Does the seasoned-board steak method work? Roel loves the flavour and simplicity. He questions the claim that the steak sucks up the dressing like a sponge: what the video clearly shows is the sliced meat being mixed through herbs, juices and fat. His barbecue version adds another layer of flavour while keeping the dressing on the board.
The skillet in the video

A cast iron crust for the first test

Roel uses the PitmasterX hand-polished cast iron skillet to try the pan-cooked version. He highlights its smooth cooking surface and watches the crust as the steak sears. The pan needs time to heat through before the meat goes in.

Roel cooking the first steak in the PitmasterX cast iron skillet
The first steak cooks in the PitmasterX hand-polished cast iron skillet.
Shop the hand-polished skillet

What is the viral seasoned-board steak method?

The method moves the seasoning to the end of the cook. The steak goes into a hot pan without an initial seasoning layer. Meanwhile, herbs, garlic, lemon, salt and pepper go onto a cutting board. The cooked steak is sliced there and mixed through the dressing.

Roel first follows the approach he sees in the viral video. He uses garlic, spring onion and fresh thyme, then adds lemon and seasoning on the board. He keeps the garlic fairly coarse to stay close to what he has seen.

The butter detail matters

The original method includes butter, but Roel realises after tasting that he forgot to add it. He still loves the steak. In his view, the fat from this well-marbled piece of beef gives the dressing enough richness, so he deliberately leaves the butter out of his second version as well.

That means his first test is not an exact reproduction of every ingredient in the original video. It is the version he actually cooked and enjoyed.

Roel slicing the first steak directly over herbs on the wooden board
The first steak is sliced and mixed through the herbs on the board.

Why his pan result is already a success

The steak develops a crust, and the chopped herbs and cooking juices create a dressing that reminds Roel of chimichurri. He finds the result a little too lemony for his taste, but likes how little work it takes to get so much flavour.

He also points out a detail that a short video can hide: pan preparation. He preheats his skillet and uses a fatty steak for this no-added-oil trial. That particular combination is what viewers see; the result is not a promise that any steak will release cleanly from any pan.

Does the steak absorb the dressing like a sponge?

The viral explanation says that a steak pushes liquid out while cooking, then draws the board dressing back in as it cools. Roel is unconvinced by that explanation, even though he enjoys the result.

What he can show is simple: slicing exposes more surfaces, and turning the slices through the dressing coats them with herbs, lemon, fat and meat juices. The flavour is there without needing to prove that the dressing has travelled deep into the steak.

The video does not measure absorption. Roel’s useful distinction is between liking a technique and accepting every explanation attached to it. His second cook keeps the seasoned board and changes how he builds the steak’s flavour before it gets there.

Roel’s upgrade: smoke, sear and a more balanced dressing

For the second steak, Roel fires up the Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle. He still leaves the meat unseasoned before cooking, preserving the main idea of the test, but begins over indirect heat and adds smoke wood before the final sear.

He uses the ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10 to check what is happening inside the steak. This second piece is thinner, so he adjusts his usual reverse-sear routine and moves to direct heat sooner. He does not treat the two steaks as if they were identical.

The second steak searing over charcoal on the Napoleon Kettle Pro
Roel uses the Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle to add smoke and a charcoal finish.

Finer garlic, less lemon

Roel grates a smaller amount of garlic and mixes it with a little lemon juice and salt, letting that mixture sit while he prepares the herbs. His aim is a dressing that is easier to distribute and less overpowering than the first version.

He replaces the spring onion with finely cut chives, keeps tender thyme and adds parsley. These choices are about the flavour and texture he wants in each bite. At the final tasting, he says the garlic and lemon feel better balanced.

Roel finely grating garlic for his revised board dressing
For the second dressing, Roel adjusts the garlic, lemon and herbs.

Keep the finish on the board

After the direct-heat finish, the steak goes onto the herbs and is sliced there. Roel keeps that serving style from the original method rather than turning it into a separate sauce recipe.

He enjoys the added smoke and char alongside the fresher dressing. The idea is still easy to recognise: cook the steak, then bring the flavour together on the board.

The grilled steak being sliced on the second herb dressing
The barbecue version keeps the same idea: slice the steak onto the seasoned board.

Pan-cooked steak vs the barbecue version

In Roel’s test First version Barbecue version
Cooking method Hot cast iron skillet. Indirect cooking with smoke, followed by direct searing on the Kettle Pro.
Seasoning Added on the board, not before cooking. The same board-seasoning principle.
Herbs and garlic Coarser garlic, spring onion and thyme. Less garlic, grated finer; chives, thyme and parsley.
Butter Omitted by accident. Omitted deliberately after enjoying the first result.
Flavour Very good and simple, but a little too lemony for Roel. More smoke and char; garlic and lemon better balanced for his taste.

What the comparison can tell you

Roel prefers his revised version, but he changes several things at once: the cooking method, the thickness of the steak and the dressing. The video therefore cannot isolate one change as the reason for the improvement.

It does show a useful way to adapt an idea. Keep the part that works for you — here, the fresh dressing on the cutting board — and adjust the rest to suit your taste. Roel also recognises why someone might prefer the original pan method: it is very straightforward.

What to take into your next steak cook

  • Let the board do the final seasoning. Mix the sliced steak through the dressing so the herbs and juices reach the pieces you serve.
  • Balance the lemon and garlic. Roel’s main dressing changes are smaller amounts and finer texture.
  • Use the cooking method for the flavour you want. His skillet gives him the first crust; the kettle adds smoke and a charcoal finish.
  • Allow for the steak in front of you. The thinner second steak needs a different finish from his usual thick-steak routine.

Use a clean board for the herbs and cooked steak. The appeal is a fresh dressing mixed at the moment of serving, with the cooking juices becoming part of the dish.

Equipment used

Main sponsor

Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle

The charcoal barbecue used for Roel’s second version. Its indirect and direct cooking areas let him add smoke first and then give the steak its seared finish.

Explore the Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle

ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10

The instant-read thermometer used to check the steak before the final sear. It lets Roel judge the centre of the meat alongside what he can see on the outside.

Current partner offer: use code PITMASTERX for 25% off in the ChefsTemp shop.

Shop the Finaltouch X10

For the first test, Roel uses the PitmasterX hand-polished cast iron skillet. A sharp knife, a clean board and a fine grater complete the preparation shown in the video.

Napoleon is the main sponsor. ChefsTemp is the thermometer partner. The equipment buttons link to the sponsors’ official websites.

Watch the seasoned-board steak comparison

Watch the full video on YouTube

More steak technique tests

Powrót do blogu