Velveted beef held with chopsticks after frying

Velveting Beef Tested: Chinese-Style Tenderness on a Kamado

Roel Westra

Why does beef in a Chinese restaurant often feel so different from a plain strip of beef fried at home? Roel tests a velveting method inspired by Dim Sim Lim, better known as Wok God, then compares the treated and untreated beef before turning the result into a bowl of noodles.

Does velveting make beef more tender? In this PitmasterX test, Roel finds the treated beef much softer, more flavourful and juicier-feeling than the untreated batch. The method changes several things together: slicing, seasoning, added water and the coating. His verdict is enthusiastic, but he firmly rejects the idea that it turns ordinary beef into Japanese Wagyu.

Start with the grain, then look at the thickness

Roel uses a lean piece of beef from his neighbour’s cow, describing it as comparable to a round or silverside cut. Before adding anything, he checks which way the muscle fibres run. Where the grain changes direction, he adjusts his slicing.

Roel checking the grain of the beef before slicing
Roel checks the grain before cutting thin slices across it.

His first observation is easy to overlook when watching a quick online demonstration: the slices are very thin. Cutting across the grain and keeping the slices thin are part of the method, before the beef ever reaches the marinade or the wok.

That matters when interpreting the result. This is a test of the complete preparation shown in the video, including the knife work. It does not isolate a single powder as the explanation for everything that follows.

What goes into this velveting treatment?

In this version, the beef is massaged with baking soda and water, then seasoned with salt, sugar, chicken powder, white pepper, MSG, sesame oil, rice wine and dark soy sauce. Cornstarch is added to coat the slices.

A thin beef slice after the velveting treatment
The beef after the seasoning and starch coating have been mixed in.

Texture and flavour change together

The chicken powder, MSG, soy sauce and other seasonings make the treated batch a very different starting point from the plain beef. Roel describes the seasoning as a big boost in savoury flavour. By the time the coating is mixed in, the slices also look noticeably different.

He questions several quantities while following the original clip and estimates some additions by eye. The useful lesson here is the sequence and the comparison, rather than treating this experiment as a precisely measured formula.

The video calls the process velveting. Here, that means the complete treatment of thin beef slices with baking soda, water, flavourings and a starch coating before frying. It is the version Roel tests in this episode, rather than a claim that every Chinese restaurant prepares beef the same way.

Using the Monolith Avantgarde for the wok cook

The original demonstration uses a powerful wok burner. Roel takes the experiment outside and uses the Monolith Avantgarde ceramic barbecue as his heat source. The aim is to give the pan the heat needed for this fast, active style of cooking.

Roel frying beef on the Monolith Avantgarde
The Monolith Avantgarde provides the heat for Roel’s outdoor wok test.

He prepares the pan, adds sunflower oil and cooks the plain and treated beef in separate batches. Later, the same setup is used for the aromatics, vegetables and noodles. The frying stage and the final toss are distinct parts of the cook.

Watch what happens when the vegetables go in: Roel reacts to the intensity of the heat and backs it down. Keeping the ingredients ready and adjusting the heat are part of the work; this is a cook that needs his attention throughout.

Explore the Monolith Avantgarde

Plain beef versus velveted beef: what Roel notices

The treated beef lifted from the frying oil
The treated batch after frying, ready for comparison and tasting.

Untreated beef

The plain batch looks grey in the comparison. Roel finds it bland and chewy, with the prolonged chew he associates with a tough piece of beef cooked hard.

Velveted beef

The treated batch looks more appealing to him. He describes it as very soft and full of flavour, with a slightly springy, almost gummy first bite that then becomes much more enjoyable and feels juicy.

A convincing tasting result, with a specific scope

Roel clearly prefers the treated batch. The comparison shows what this whole preparation did in his cook. Because seasoning, water and coating all change together, it cannot tell us how much of the difference comes from each individual addition.

The darker colour also reflects the treatment, including dark soy sauce. Appearance alone is not a measurement of tenderness or juiciness; Roel’s tasting is the evidence for his texture and flavour verdict.

Does it turn cheap beef into Wagyu?

No. Roel explicitly says the result is nowhere near Japanese Wagyu. He enjoys the transformation on its own terms: a lean cut becomes a much more enjoyable ingredient for this style of dish. The internet comparison gets his attention, but it is not his final conclusion.

The payoff: beef that works in the finished dish

After the side-by-side tasting, Roel combines the beef with ginger, garlic, peanuts, chilli oil, vegetables, noodles and sauce ingredients. He especially enjoys the crisp vegetables and the flavour of the finished bowl.

Roel tasting the finished bowl of beef noodles
The treated beef becomes part of the finished noodle dish.

This second stage gives the experiment context. The treated beef is not intended to imitate a grilled steak. It becomes part of a wok dish in which the texture of the meat, the vegetables and the sauce need to work together.

His takeaway is straightforward: thin slicing and this complete treatment made a worthwhile difference in his test. The Monolith setup then gave him a way to explore wok cooking outdoors.

Questions from the test

Is baking soda the same as cornstarch?

No. They are separate additions in this video: baking soda goes into the beef earlier, while cornstarch is mixed in later as part of the coating. Roel uses both in the tested treatment.

Can this be tested on a ceramic barbecue?

Yes. Roel uses the Monolith Avantgarde for this episode. His cook shows that setup in action; it does not measure its burner output against the restaurant wok burner in the original clip.

Is this the same test as velveted chicken wings?

No. The cut, preparation and cooking method differ. For the separate barbecue experiment, read our velveting chicken wings test.

Equipment for this cook

MAIN SPONSOR

Monolith Avantgarde

The ceramic barbecue used for the outdoor wok setup. Explore the Avantgarde range and the official equipment options for building your own setup.

Explore the Monolith Avantgarde

ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10

The thermometer selected for this episode. Its rotating probe and clear display make it a practical tool for quick spot checks while cooking.

Current partner offer: use code PITMASTERX for 25% off in the ChefsTemp shop.

Shop the Finaltouch X10

Monolith is the main sponsor of this video. ChefsTemp is the thermometer partner. The equipment links above are sponsor links.

Watch the beef velveting test

Original PitmasterX video: This is How Chinese Restaurants Tenderize Beef !!! · Published 13 June 2026.

Tested by Roel Westra

Roel is the cook behind PitmasterX. This article is based on his filmed comparison, its transcript and original video frames. The verdict describes his experience of the two batches in this cook.

Explore another Monolith technique in our foil-boat beef ribs test.

Tilbake til bloggen