Full belly ribs with a dark smoked bark, held up by Roel after cooking in the Borniak 150

Full Belly Ribs vs St. Louis: What the Extra Meat Adds

Roel Westra

St. Louis-style ribs look tidy on the board: a rectangular rack, straight bones and neat portions. In this cook, Roel keeps the full belly rib rack instead. The extra meat, fat and rib-tip section are exactly what make the finished ribs worth the effort for him.

Why keep the full belly ribs?

Keeping the rack untrimmed preserves the meaty, fatty section that would be removed to make a St. Louis-style rack. Roel smokes it hanging in the Borniak 150, stops adding smoke once the colour is right, and finishes it unwrapped until the meat releases easily from the bones. The trade-off is an irregular rack with cartilage to remove after cooking.

Full belly ribs vs St. Louis-style ribs: what changes?

The distinction is how much of the lower rib rack is kept. Roel shows the full belly ribs left after the baby backs have been removed, then traces where he would trim them to create the familiar St. Louis shape.

Roel showing the full raw belly rib rack before trimming or seasoning
The full rack before trimming: Roel keeps the extra section of meat, fat and cartilage.

Baby back ribs

The upper rib section, removed before Roel shows the belly rack. He likes their layer of meat and fat; the unusually large baby backs in this video came from pigs he raised himself.

St. Louis-style ribs

A lower rib rack trimmed into a more regular rectangle, with the rib-tip section removed. You get neat presentation and straightforward portions, with less of the cartilage-bearing edge.

Full belly ribs

The lower rack with the additional section still attached. It keeps more of the meat and fat Roel enjoys, together with cartilage that needs attention when serving.

What to ask your butcher

Show your butcher the whole rack at the start of the video and explain that you want to keep the belly-side rib-tip section rather than trim it to a St. Louis rectangle. Ask to see the meat coverage and the fatty section along the edge. The visible cut is a better reference than relying on a name alone.

This rack comes from Roel's own pigs, which he prepared with his butcher. Its generous size and meat coverage are part of the result. Judge the piece in front of you when choosing a rack for your own smoker.

Why Roel hangs the ribs in the Borniak

Roel scores the membrane on the bone side and seasons the rack before hanging it vertically. He positions the hook with a rib behind it to give the attachment support. Hanging leaves both broad faces of the rack exposed inside the smoking chamber.

Roel placing a meat hook through the rib rack before hanging it in the smoker
The hook is placed with a rib behind it before the heavy rack is lifted into the smoker.

The Borniak BBQ 150 gives him the height for this setup. He sets the chamber to 140°C / 284°F and starts the wood-chip smoke generator. That is the setting used for this substantial, fatty rack.

The hanging mistake worth learning from

The hook holds at the beginning, but its support changes as the meat softens. Roel intends to move the rack onto a grate later in the cook. The ribs become tender sooner than he expects, pull free and drop onto the clean grates underneath.

The practical lesson: plan the move from hook to grate before the meat becomes so soft that the hook can tear through it. Keep a suitable clean support below the rack, check the attachment as the cook progresses, and support the whole piece when transferring it.

The ribs still turn out well. Roel remains enthusiastic about hanging for the smoking stage, while the dropped rack shows why the finish needs closer attention.

Smoke for colour, then keep cooking without more smoke

After about two hours of smoking, the ribs have a pronounced golden-brown colour. Roel compares the developing surface to bacon. At that point he stops the smoke generator and lets the meat continue cooking unwrapped.

Full belly ribs hanging vertically inside the Borniak smoker after the smoking stage
The colour after the smoking stage is the cue to stop adding smoke and continue cooking.

His explanation is about balance: the meat supplies the main flavour, smoke adds another layer, and the seasoning completes it. More smoke is not automatically the goal once the rack has the colour and smoky character he wants.

The separate heat and smoke controls on the Borniak make that change straightforward. The ribs can keep tenderising while the smoke supply is off. The two-hour checkpoint is the smoking stage in this cook; the video does not establish a fixed total cooking time for every rack.

Use core temperature to follow progress, then check tenderness

Roel inserts the wireless ChefsTemp ProTemp 2 Plus probe and sets an app notification at 93°C / 199°F. He describes 92–96°C / 198–205°F as the range in which he checks these ribs for the texture he wants.

Roel inserting a wireless ChefsTemp probe into the hanging ribs
A wireless probe follows the core temperature while the rack continues cooking.

The reading tells him when to pay attention; the final judgement comes from how the meat feels and releases. At the end, the rack is soft enough to pull apart, bones come away easily, and the cartilage section can be worked free. He rests this rack for about 10 minutes before demonstrating the result.

Roel demonstrating how easily a bone separates from the tender smoked ribs
The finished rack releases its bones easily, revealing the soft meat beneath the bark.

Why the extra section wins Roel over

The reward is the combination of bark and the rich, soft meat along the lower edge. Keeping that section means dealing with cartilage, but the finished texture makes the extra work worthwhile for Roel. His verdict is a personal assessment of this rack: he would rather keep and smoke the full piece than trim away the part he particularly enjoys.

St. Louis-style ribs remain useful when even portions and a tidy shape are your priority. If you enjoy the richer edge meat and are happy to separate the cartilage after cooking, this full belly rack gives you a good reason to ask your butcher for a different cut.

Equipment and partner links

Main sponsor

Borniak BBQ 150

The cabinet smoker used for this cook provides room to hang the full rack. Its separate heat and smoke controls let Roel stop adding smoke when the colour is right and continue cooking until the ribs are tender.

View the Borniak BBQ 150 at Borniak
Follow the core temperature

ChefsTemp ProTemp 2 Plus

The wireless probe follows the ribs while they cook, and the ChefsTemp app provides a notification at Roel's chosen target. This makes it easier to track progress while still checking the meat itself for tenderness.

Use code PITMASTERX for 25% off in the ChefsTemp shop.

Shop the ChefsTemp ProTemp 2 Plus

For the hanging setup, use suitable meat hooks and a hanging bar, with a clean grate below and heatproof gloves to support the rack when moving it.

Borniak is the main sponsor of this video. ChefsTemp also supports PitmasterX; the equipment links above are partner links.

Questions about full belly ribs

Are full belly ribs and St. Louis ribs the same cut?

They come from the same lower rib area, but St. Louis-style trimming removes the rib-tip section to make a neater rack. Roel keeps that additional section attached in this cook.

Do the ribs stay hanging until they are done?

No. Roel plans to finish them on a grate, and this rack falls from the hook before he transfers it. Support is especially important as the meat becomes tender.

Does he smoke or wrap them throughout the cook?

He stops adding smoke after about two hours, when he is happy with the colour, and continues cooking unwrapped.

What happens to the cartilage?

It stays in the rack during cooking. Once the meat is tender, Roel works the cartilage free before eating that section.

Watch the full video

Watch on YouTube

  1. 00:00 — Why keep the full belly ribs?
  2. 00:10 — Baby backs, St. Louis and belly ribs
  3. 01:00 — The pigs and butchered racks
  4. 01:22 — Recognising the full belly cut
  5. 01:52 — Membrane and Texas Seasoning
  6. 02:08 — Hanging the rack
  7. 02:25 — Borniak temperature and smoke
  8. 03:04 — The colour after two hours
  9. 03:28 — Wireless temperature monitoring
  10. 04:14 — When the hook loses its hold
  11. 05:09 — The finished rack
  12. 05:46 — Bones, cartilage and the verdict
Roel Westra · PitmasterX

Based on Roel's original full belly ribs cook. All photographs are original frames from the video.

Explore another rib setup in our guide to smoking ribs on a gas grill, or read how Roel manages bark, wrapping and juices when making pulled pork in the Borniak.

Tilbake til bloggen