Dry-aged ribeye after charcoal grilling, sliced to show the interior

Dry-Aged vs Wet-Aged Steak: Our 35-Day Ribeye Test

Roel Westra
Dry-aged ribeye after charcoal grilling, sliced to show the interior
The dry-aged ribeye after grilling. Its extra flavour won me over, but the wet-aged steak came much closer than expected.

Same animal. Same cut. Five weeks of ageing. I expected dry-aged ribeye to beat wet-aged ribeye by a mile. Instead, the vacuum-packed steak came surprisingly close. Here is what changed in tenderness, flavour and trimming—and when I would pay extra for dry ageing.

For your next steak night

Make the next cook your own

PitmasterX Beef Seasoning

This ageing comparison used salt only. For a different flavour on your next steak night, try PitmasterX Beef Seasoning. Keep the same temperature control and let the seasoning be the part you change.

Shop PitmasterX Beef Seasoning

A 35-day comparison using beef from the same animal

For this experiment, we used beef from our neighbour’s 18-month-old Black Angus–Holstein cross. Working with my butcher let me choose corresponding ribeye cuts from the same animal: one went into a vacuum bag under refrigeration; the other went into the butcher’s dry-ageing cabinet.

That matters because breed, feeding and age can all differ when you buy two unrelated steaks. Using the same animal reduces those differences. It does not make this a universal ranking: this was one animal, one ageing period and one tasting session.

Cut
Ribeye
Ageing period
35 days / 5 weeks
Seasoning in the test
Salt only
After salting
About 4 hours refrigerated
Roel Westra and his butcher examining the beef rib section before the ageing comparison
At the butcher: selecting beef from the same animal for the two ageing methods.

I had also eaten steak from this animal roughly seven days after butchering. It was already very good. My impression after five weeks was that both ageing methods had taken tenderness to another level. The earlier meal was a separate experience, not a simultaneous third sample.

What is the difference between dry-aged and wet-aged steak?

Wet ageing matures beef in vacuum packaging under refrigeration. Dry ageing matures unpackaged beef in a controlled refrigerated environment; its dried outer surface is trimmed before cooking. EFSA describes both as established ageing methods, with safety depending on controlled processing conditions. Read EFSA’s explanation.

What differs between the methods—and what happened in our test
Question Wet-aged Dry-aged
How is it aged? Vacuum-packed and refrigerated. Unpackaged in the butcher’s controlled cabinet.
Where does moisture go? Liquid released by the beef remains in the bag. Moisture can evaporate from the exposed surface.
What gets trimmed? More exterior material than I expected in this particular test. The dried exterior and strongly flavoured outside fat.
How did it taste? Exceptionally tender, with a very satisfying beef flavour. Exceptionally tender, with a little extra nutty, savoury depth.
My buying choice A strong option when value matters most. A worthwhile treat when that extra flavour is what you want.

Before cooking, I expected the wet-aged steak to stay closer to its original flavour and the dry-aged steak to develop more nuttiness and umami. Those were expectations. The tasting—not the price tag—had to decide how much difference they made.

Trimming changed the comparison

The wet-aged beef surprised me first. After opening the bag, I removed more of the outside than I had expected, and the finished steaks were smaller than I had pictured. Keeping moisture in a bag does not mean every gram of the original piece ends up on your plate.

The dry-aged beef was more work to trim, but the waste looked smaller than I had expected. I removed the dried exterior and much of the outside fat because I expected that fat to taste too intense. I left some on one steak to explore the difference; the transcript does not establish a separate final verdict on that fat.

We did not record starting and finished weights. These observations therefore cannot tell us which method had the higher measured yield. They do show why the usable steak after trimming matters more than the size of the untrimmed roast.

How we prepared and grilled the steaks

  1. Trim and portion the aged ribeyes

    After trimming, I kept the steaks relatively thick to get a useful portion from the smaller pieces, then tied them with butcher’s twine.

  2. Season simply and refrigerate

    I used salt on both steaks and returned them to the fridge for about four hours. Keeping the seasoning the same helped the beef remain the focus of the comparison.

  3. Grill over charcoal

    I used the Napoleon Professional Charcoal Grill. Its adjustable charcoal bed lets you change the distance between the coals and the steak; raising or lowering it gives you another way to control the heat.

  4. Monitor the centre, then slice and compare

    The ChefsTemp ProTemp 2 Plus monitored the steak’s internal temperature during the cook. The episode does not state an exact cooking time, pull temperature or resting time, so those numbers are not presented here as part of the tested method.

This is a report of our comparison. If you are cooking your own steak, follow appropriate food-safety guidance and use a thermometer; the colour of a sliced steak alone does not verify a safe internal temperature.

The taste test: both were excellent

Wet-aged: the surprise of the experiment

The wet-aged steak had a beautiful crust and was extraordinarily tender. After the trimming, the balance of meat and fat worked exactly as I wanted. This was already a steak I would happily cook and eat again.

Dry-aged: a small but noticeable flavour advantage

The dry-aged steak was also extremely tender, with some of the nutty, umami character I had hoped for. At 35 days, that flavour was present without overwhelming the steak. It was my favourite—but only narrowly.

In the video I described the improvement as “maybe 5%.” That is my personal way of describing a small preference, not a measured percentage or a scientific score. It should not be read as a rule that dry-aged beef is always 5% better.

Is dry-aged steak worth the extra money?

For an occasional steak where you specifically want dry-aged flavour, I can see the appeal. You are paying for time, cabinet space, controlled conditions and the effect of moisture loss and trimming on the saleable cut.

For a regular steak night, this test made a strong case for good wet-aged beef. It delivered remarkable tenderness and came much closer to the dry-aged steak than I had expected. We did not calculate costs per finished portion, so this is a buying judgement rather than a measured saving.

Ask your butcher how the beef was aged, how long it matured and whether the price is for a ready-trimmed steak. Those details make the comparison more useful than choosing on the words “dry-aged” alone.

Equipment used in this episode

Main sponsor · Charcoal grill

Napoleon Professional Charcoal Grill

The grill’s adjustable charcoal bed was the useful feature for this cook: raise it for close, intense searing or lower it to increase the distance from the heat. Napoleon lists this grill as the Professional 605 Charcoal Cart, PRO605CSS.

Explore the Professional 605 at Napoleon

Temperature monitoring · Video sponsor

ChefsTemp ProTemp 2 Plus

The wireless thermometer used in this cook. Monitor the steak’s internal temperature while it grills, so you can judge progress without relying only on the crust. Follow the temperature on the display or in the ChefsTemp app.

Save 25% with code PITMASTERX
Enter the code at ChefsTemp checkout.

Limited-time offer, expected until mid-January 2027. ChefsTemp’s current terms apply; check the final discount at checkout.

Shop the ProTemp 2 Plus at ChefsTemp

Also used: charcoal, butcher’s twine, a sharp trimming knife, tongs and a cutting board. The ageing took place before the cook; buying ready-aged steaks avoids needing an ageing cabinet for your own comparison.

Watch the complete dry-aged vs wet-aged experiment

No more DEBATE!! Dry aged vs Wet aged Steak EXPERIMENT · 12 min 24 sec · Published 15 August 2026

Dry-aged and wet-aged steak questions

Which steak was more tender?

Both were exceptionally tender in this test. My narrow preference for dry-aged was about the overall eating experience and extra flavour, not a measured tenderness difference.

Does dry ageing always beat wet ageing?

This comparison cannot establish that. Ageing duration, the starting beef and personal taste matter. At 35 days, I preferred dry-aged only slightly.

Does wet-aged beef have no trimming loss?

No. Our wet-aged cut needed more trimming than I expected. We did not weigh the waste, so we cannot give a reliable percentage for either method.

Is four hours of salting the same as ageing?

No. The beef had already matured for five weeks. The roughly four-hour refrigerated period happened after portioning and salting, before grilling.

Can I wet-age any supermarket steak for five weeks?

Do not use this experiment as a home storage timetable. Follow the product’s storage and use-by instructions, or ask a butcher for beef already matured under controlled conditions.

Ageing is only part of the story. We also separated the cap and eye to compare their flavour and texture: read our ribeye cap vs ribeye charcoal test.

About this article

Roel Westra is the host of PitmasterX. The observations and verdict come from his filmed comparison and supplied transcript. The photos show this experiment. General ageing and storage context is checked against EFSA and UK food-safety guidance; equipment details are checked against Napoleon. Sponsor credits are taken from the video description.

Original PitmasterX video · EFSA: controlled meat ageing · Food date labels

Tilbake til bloggen