A cross-section of cooked brisket showing the meat and rendered fat

Gas Grill Brisket vs Offset Smoker: Our Blind Taste Test

Roel Westra

Can you make a brisket on a gas grill that holds its own against an offset smoker? I cooked two briskets, worked to bring their bark and tenderness close together, and asked Jim to taste them blind. He preferred the gas-grilled brisket—and thought it had come from the offset.

A cross-section of cooked brisket showing the meat and rendered fat
Gas Grill Brisket vs Offset Smoker: Our Blind Taste Test

Give both briskets a comparable start

I begin with two well-marbled briskets from the same herd and weigh them before and after trimming. One starts much heavier, yet the usable weights end up surprisingly close after removing thin sections and excess fat. For this pair, the bigger purchase did not deliver proportionally more brisket to serve.

The meat trimmings go through the grinder and into the freezer to combine with leaner beef later. The fat trimmings are reserved for rendering. That rendered fat will return to the briskets during the wrapped stage.

Both briskets are dry-brined overnight in the fridge. In this cook I use salt at around 2% of the trimmed meat weight, then add a generous coating of pepper the next day. There is no commercial seasoning blend in this test.

The Napoleon gas grill in the outdoor cooking area
The gas grill needs enough space to keep a full brisket away from direct heat.

The gas grill setup is the important part

On the offset, the thick end of the brisket faces the fire. I start with oak, then use a combination of oak and beech. The fat trimmings render in a separate pan.

On the Napoleon Prestige 665 setup, the brisket sits above trays of warm water, raised away from the burners. Smoker boxes provide the wood smoke. The arrangement creates an indirect cooking space rather than leaving the meat directly over a flame.

In the video I rearrange grates and the removable heat deflectors to accommodate the smoker boxes. Use the accessory placement approved for your particular grill. The useful principle is a stable indirect zone with room for the brisket and controlled smoke—not a universal arrangement for every gas barbecue.

I deliberately use separate smoker boxes for the comparison. The built-in smoking feature discussed in the video is not the basis of the result. A suitably sized gas grill and a workable smoking setup are the point of the experiment.

Follow the bark instead of assuming the offset will win

I replenish the gas grill’s wood chips approximately every 30 minutes during the first stage. The offset also needs regular attention. In this cook, using gas does not mean walking away from the smoking process.

The surprising development is how quickly the bark builds on the gas grill brisket. It becomes dark and attractive while the offset brisket is still catching up. I stop adding chips to the gas grill once the colour is where I want it.

On the offset, I move the pan of rendering fat farther back to expose the brisket more directly to the moving hot air. After more than seven hours, both briskets have the dark, developed exterior I want. That is when I wrap: the bark is ready, so the focus shifts to tenderness.

Wrapping, checking tenderness and holding

Each brisket goes into butcher’s paper with some of the rendered beef tallow. They continue cooking until the core reaches approximately 94°C / 201°F and the meat feels soft and tender. The ChefsTemp S2 tracks the temperature; the feel of the meat supplies the second part of the decision.

The gas grill brisket finishes first, with the offset following shortly afterwards. I then add a tight outer foil layer and hold both overnight in an oven set to 60°C / 140°F. This is the holding stage shown in the video, and it is a major part of this particular comparison.

On slicing, both have rendered fat and a similar meat structure. The offset brisket shows a clearer smoke ring. The gas grill brisket has less visible ring, but its bark looks excellent. Appearance alone cannot settle the flavour question.

Jim tasting brisket while wearing a blindfold
Jim tastes the briskets without seeing which cooker they came from.

Jim’s blind tasting verdict

Jim enjoys both samples. He describes their tenderness as very similar, but finds the second sample’s smoke flavour more pronounced. He prefers that one and guesses it is the offset brisket.

The reveal is the opposite: his favourite is the gas grill brisket. The first sample, from the offset, comes across as a little more beef-forward to him.

That is a result from two briskets and one taster, not proof that every gas grill will beat every offset. It does show that the gas grill is capable of far more than quick burgers and steaks. Good meat, an indirect setup, managed smoke, a developed bark and a careful finish can produce a brisket that surprises an experienced eater.

If you already own a large gas grill, this test gives you a reason to explore what it can do. The lesson is in the cooking process—and in tasting the result before deciding which fuel must be better.

Equipment

Use code PITMASTERX for 25% off at ChefsTemp.

Watch the cook

Watch on YouTube

In this video

By Roel Westra — PitmasterX. Based on the original cook shown in the video.

Torna al blog