Chuck, whole blade and hanger steak arranged on a Napoleon kettle grill

3 Brisket Alternatives: Chuck, Whole Blade and Hanger Steak

Roel Westra

Barbecue should turn an ordinary cut into something you are excited to eat. When a whole brisket feels like too much money or too much meat, I look elsewhere on the animal. For this cook, I put chuck, whole blade and hanger steak through the same low-and-slow treatment on the Napoleon kettle grill.

My pick for a brisket-style family cook: chuck. The whole blade was juicy but had a milder flavour and a softer bark. The hanger steak delivered the strongest-looking bark and a lot of flavour, although the piece I cooked was too small to feed four.

Three cuts worth discussing with your butcher

The video’s “under $30” title describes the budget behind this particular experiment. Your local price, the weight of the piece and how much preparation the butcher has done will determine the actual cost. The useful idea is to compare larger, less-trimmed cuts with smaller portions already prepared for steak cooking.

1. Chuck: my all-round favourite

I started with a large shoulder cut and portioned it into thick pieces of roughly 1.5 kg / 3.3 lb. That gives more exposed surface for seasoning, smoke and bark than leaving the entire shoulder in one enormous piece.

Chuck brings a strong beef flavour and enough fat to suit this style of cooking. Buying a larger piece also gives you options: cook one portion now and keep the rest for another meal. You do not have to turn the entire purchase into one barbecue session.

Raw chuck portion on a wire rack before smoking
A thick chuck portion gives plenty of surface for seasoning and smoke.

2. Whole blade: the cut before flat iron steaks

The second piece was whole blade, the cut from which flat iron steaks can be prepared. Here, the central seam was still present. I divided the approximately 3 kg piece in half and kept the other half for another day.

I left the fat cap on, scored it, and applied a lighter coating of Texas Seasoning to that side, with more on the exposed meat. The central seam becomes a defining part of the finished texture, so this is a different eating experience from a trimmed flat iron steak.

Whole blade beef with its fat cap before seasoning
The fat cap stays on the whole blade for this cook.

3. Hanger steak: big flavour in a smaller piece

Hanger steak is often cooked quickly as a steak. In this experiment, I treated it as barbecue instead: seasoning, smoke, a tallow wrap and a long finish. Its shape and smaller size made it an interesting comparison with the two larger shoulder portions.

Raw hanger steak on a wire rack
The hanger steak is the smallest of the three alternatives in this test.

The same low-and-slow approach for all three

I set up the Napoleon kettle grill for indirect cooking using a snake of coconut briquettes, with whiskey-barrel wood chunks for smoke. The initial cooking temperature was 120°C / 248°F. The point of the snake is a gradually advancing fire, giving these cuts time to develop colour.

After about three hours, I liked the mahogany colour. Because these were smaller pieces than a full brisket, I chose to wrap at that stage rather than keep extending the unwrapped cook. Each piece went into aluminium foil with beef tallow; I used less for the blade because it still had its fat cap.

Roel checking beef on the Napoleon kettle grill
Checking colour before the beef moves into the wrapped stage.

The wrapped beef went back onto the barbecue. I kept the heat around 120°C, with 140°C / 284°F discussed as an option, and cooked the meat to approximately 92–94°C / 198–201°F. Temperature was a useful guide, with tenderness and the way the meat handled providing the final context.

For this cook, I then let the temperature come down before holding the beef at 63°C / 145°F for six hours. That was part of my preparation in the video, not a claim that every piece needs exactly the same schedule. The ChefsTemp helped me follow the temperatures through the cook.

The taste test: which would I cook again?

Roel’s results from this cook
Cut What stood out The trade-off
Chuck Strong beef flavour, good bark and juicy slices My favourite all-round option for a family-sized cook
Whole blade Very juicy, with a soft central seam Less pronounced bark and milder flavour than the chuck
Hanger Dark, crusty bark and excellent flavour The small piece I cooked would not feed four people
Sliced smoked beef with a dark bark on a wooden board
The finished beef shows the bark and tender interior that make these cuts interesting alternatives.

The chuck was the clearest answer to the original question. It gave me the satisfying combination of bark, tenderness and beef flavour I look for in brisket, in a portion that worked for a family meal.

The blade was still a good result, although the central seam will appeal more to some people than others. The hanger was the surprise for its bark and flavour. I would happily cook it again, while planning the quantity around the actual size of the piece.

Want to see another way to cook chuck? Read the 48 vs 72-hour smoked chuck experiment.

Watch all three cuts from start to finish

Watch on YouTube

  1. 00:00 — Why look beyond brisket?
  2. 02:24 — The snake method and smoke
  3. 02:44 — Chuck and the shoulder cut
  4. 04:21 — Seasoning the chuck
  5. 04:49 — Whole blade before flat iron steaks
  6. 05:49 — The central seam and fat cap
  7. 06:40 — Hanger steak
  8. 08:26 — Colour after three hours
  9. 08:45 — Wrapping with beef tallow
  10. 10:04 — The six-hour hold
  11. 10:14 — Chuck taste test
  12. 10:57 — Whole blade taste test
  13. 12:03 — Hanger steak taste test
  14. 13:13 — Final verdict

Equipment and seasoning

Made possible by Napoleon. ChefsTemp is a PitmasterX partner. PitmasterX Texas Seasoning is our own product.

Roel Westra · PitmasterX
Based on the video published on 2 April 2026.

Retour au blog