Three beef cuts grilling over charcoal with visible flames on the Napoleon Apollo 22

Ribeye Cap vs Ribeye: What Our Charcoal Test Revealed

Roel Westra
Three beef cuts grilling over charcoal with visible flames on the Napoleon Apollo 22
The three cuts grilling over charcoal on the Napoleon Apollo 22, before the side-by-side tasting.

Is ribeye cap really better than the rest of a ribeye? I went to the butcher expecting my favourite part of the steak to win. We separated three cuts from the same animal, grilled them over charcoal and tasted them side by side. The result made a strong case for keeping your ribeye together.

For your next steak night

Make the next cook your own

PitmasterX Beef Seasoning

We used only salt for this comparison. If you want to explore a different flavour on your next steak cook, try PitmasterX Beef Seasoning. Keep the same temperature control and let the seasoning be the part you change.

Explore PitmasterX Beef Seasoning

What is ribeye cap steak?

The ribeye cap, commonly called spinalis dorsi, is the marbled muscle around the outside of the ribeye’s central eye. Separated from the eye, it can be portioned into ribeye cap steaks. The Beef Checkoff’s cut guide identifies it as a grilling cut and describes portioning across the muscle fibres.

That name matters at the butcher. In this video, the outer piece initially discussed as a rib cap is different from the spinalis inside. We call that third piece the “belly part,” as it is described in the video. We are not using that phrase as a precise, universal butcher’s name. Show your butcher the cutting sequence at 1:14 if you want to repeat this particular comparison.

You do not need a whole rib section to try the cap. Ask for a ribeye cap steak, or choose a whole ribeye if you want to enjoy the cap and eye together.

How we set up the comparison

The beef came from a cow bought from our next-door neighbour and hung for 14 days before this cutting session. At the butcher’s, we separated the cap, the eye and the outer piece. We cut comparable portions and kept the seasoning to salt so a rub or sauce would not dominate the differences.

Beef
Three cuts from the same animal
Ageing
14 days before cutting
Seasoning
Salt only
Cooking
Charcoal, with direct and indirect zones

This is our experience of this beef on this day, rather than a universal ranking. We did not record steak weights, exact cooking times or final measured temperatures for each sample. Those limits matter when comparing the results with a different animal, thickness or grill setup.

Ribeye cap vs eye: what we tasted

Our observations from this side-by-side tasting
Cut Flavour Texture and verdict
Outer “belly part” The most pronounced beef flavour. Juicy and fatty, but noticeably more chewy than the other two cuts.
Ribeye cap / spinalis Rich and enjoyable; very close to the eye in our final comparison. A clear step up in tenderness from the outer piece, with plenty of juiciness.
Eye of the ribeye Very similar to the cap. A finer texture that felt slightly more tender. It did not need the cap to be an excellent steak.

I still love ribeye cap. What changed was the idea that it is automatically a big upgrade over the eye. In this tasting, the distinction was more about texture than a dramatic difference in flavour. Keeping a ribeye intact gives you different bites in the same steak, which is part of its appeal.

Watch our verdict at 5:48 →

How to grill the steaks for your own comparison

Ingredients: ribeye cap steak and salt to taste. For a comparison, add an eye-of-ribeye steak and the outer cut agreed with your butcher. There is no marinade, sauce or spice rub in our test.

  1. Trim and portion

    Remove tough silver skin from the cap. For a side-by-side test, prepare portions of similar thickness. This makes it easier to compare the meat without a thin steak cooking much further than a thick one.

  2. Build two heat zones

    Bank the charcoal on one side of the grill and leave the other side free of coals. Light the charcoal with fire starters. The direct side develops the crust; the indirect side gives you somewhere to move the steaks when their outside is ready.

  3. Season simply

    Salt both sides. If the purpose is comparing cuts, use the same seasoning approach for each one. Keep stronger seasoning experiments for another cook.

  4. Sear, then manage the heat

    Grill directly over the hot charcoal, turning to develop the crust on both sides. Move a steak to the indirect zone and close the lid if its centre needs more time after the outside has browned. Avoid treating all three pieces as if they will finish at the same moment.

  5. Check each steak separately

    Use the ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10 to check the centre of the thickest part. Keep the sensing tip away from bone and large pockets of fat. It is a handheld thermometer: remove it after checking, rather than leaving it inside the barbecue.

  6. Rest, slice and compare

    Allow for carryover cooking, check doneness and slice across the grain. Taste the cuts side by side, noting flavour, juiciness and texture separately. A stronger beef flavour and a more tender bite are different qualities.

Three things to take to your next steak cook

  • Ask for the muscle, not just a nickname. “Rib cap” can cause confusion. Ask for the ribeye cap / spinalis and discuss the cut with your butcher.
  • Measure each piece. A cap and an eye can differ in shape and thickness. A single cooking time cannot tell you what is happening in both centres.
  • Choose the eating experience you enjoy. A whole ribeye offers contrasting textures. Separating its muscles is an interesting experiment, not an automatic improvement.

Equipment used in this video

The video is supported by Napoleon and ChefsTemp. The links below take you to the relevant products.

Main sponsor · Barbecue

Napoleon Apollo 22

For this visit to the butcher, I took the base and lid of the Apollo to make a compact charcoal-grilling setup. Banking the coals to one side gave me direct heat for the crust and an indirect area for control.

Explore the Apollo 22 at Napoleon

Temperature control

ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10

The instant-read thermometer used in this cook. Check each steak’s centre individually so you can move it off the direct heat or finish cooking it according to its actual temperature. The rotating probe helps you reach the centre from a convenient angle.

Save 25% with code PITMASTERX
Enter the code at ChefsTemp checkout.

Limited-time offer, expected until mid-January 2027. ChefsTemp’s current terms apply; check the final discount at checkout.

Shop the Finaltouch X10 at ChefsTemp

Also have ready: charcoal, fire starters, barbecue tongs, a sharp trimming knife and a cutting board.

Watch the butcher-to-barbecue test

I tried the Rib Cap Steak and I was wrong! · 7 min 6 sec · Published 6 November 2026

Ribeye cap questions, answered

Is ribeye cap the same as ribeye?

No. The cap is one part of the ribeye. Separating it gives you a different steak, while a whole ribeye includes the cap and central eye together.

Is the cap always more tender than the eye?

Our tasting did not support that as a universal claim. Both were tender; the eye’s finer texture actually felt slightly more tender to us in this comparison.

Do I need to dry-age beef for 14 days?

No. Fourteen days describes the beef in this video, not a preparation instruction you must follow. Ask your butcher for steaks ready to cook.

Can I use a whole ribeye instead?

Yes. That was our conclusion: keeping the cap and eye together gives you different textures in one steak. The two-zone grilling approach works without separating the muscles.

About this article

Roel Westra is the host of PitmasterX. This article draws on his butcher visit, charcoal cook and tasting in the linked video. The cut definition is checked against the Beef Checkoff guide; the food-safety reference is from USDA. The sponsor relationships do not change the tasting result reported here.

Original PitmasterX video · Ribeye cap cut guide · USDA temperature guidance

Regresar al blog