Steak finishing in the PitmasterX cast iron skillet on the Napoleon Kettle Pro

Gordon Ramsay’s Steak Method vs Reverse Sear: Our Test

Roel Westra

Gordon Ramsay’s pan-seared steak method is fast, familiar and full of small decisions. Roel follows the approach with striploin and his own cast iron skillet, then cooks a second steak using a reverse sear on the Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle. The question is not just which looks better, but which method is easier to control.

Pan sear or reverse sear? Roel enjoys both steaks. The pan-cooked version has a good crust and a more visible grey edge. His reverse-seared steak is more evenly pink, with a final crust built in the skillet. He prefers the control of the reverse sear, while still calling the classic pan method a good way to cook steak at home.

THE SKILLET IN THE VIDEO

One skillet, two steak methods

Roel uses the PitmasterX hand-polished cast iron skillet for his version of Ramsay’s pan cook and again for the final crust after reverse searing. Its smooth cooking surface is the feature he highlights in the video; controlling the heat and using oil still matter throughout the cook.

Roel introducing the PitmasterX hand-polished cast iron skillet
Roel introduces the hand-polished cast iron skillet used in the comparison.

Shop the hand-polished skillet

What the Ramsay method asks you to control

Roel starts with striploin steaks cut to a similar thickness. For the first cook, he follows the familiar sequence: season the meat, sear it in a preheated pan, render the fat edge, add butter and aromatics, then rest before slicing.

The short tutorial makes those decisions look almost automatic. Roel’s longer test shows how much attention goes into the pan, the crust and the centre of the steak at the same time.

A hot pan needs time, not just maximum power

Roel lets his skillet heat through before adding the steak. His point is to establish useful, controlled heat, rather than turn the burner to maximum and start immediately. The right setting depends on the pan and the heat source.

Once the steak goes in, he watches the sizzle and the colour. If the pan is too cool or the oil is smoking aggressively, he adjusts instead of treating the initial burner setting as something fixed.

Contact, turning and the fat edge

He checks that the steak makes contact with the pan and turns it repeatedly as the crust develops. He also holds the striploin’s fat edge against the pan to brown and render it. That fat-edge step is one part of Ramsay’s method he especially likes.

The quieter step: reduce the heat before basting

Once the crust is established, Roel changes the job of the pan. He lowers the heat before adding butter, garlic and thyme. The aim is to baste the steak with the flavoured butter while finishing the cook, without burning the butter and herbs.

Roel working through the pan-cooked steak and butter-basting stage
The pan cook shifts from building the crust to a gentler butter-basting stage.

He suspects that this heat adjustment happens in the original tutorial without receiving much explanation. In his own cook, he makes it explicit: the searing stage and the butter-basting stage do not need the same intensity.

Use a reading instead of relying on the finger test

Roel is sceptical of judging doneness by comparing the feel of a steak with different parts of your hand. He prefers checking the meat with a thermometer. That gives him a reading he can act on, rather than relying only on how the outside looks or feels.

After the pan cook, he rests the steak before slicing. The result has an appetising crust and a juicy interior, but he can see a band of more-cooked meat around the edge.

Roel assessing the sliced pan-cooked steak
Roel assesses the sliced steak from the pan-cooked version.

The reverse sear: cook the centre, then build the crust

For the second steak, Roel sets up the Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle with the charcoal on one side and the meat on the other. He uses the closed barbecue for the gentler first stage, with some smoke wood adding a barbecue element to the cook.

A wireless probe lets him follow the steak’s internal temperature while the lid stays closed. He then removes the steak and lets it rest with butter while preparing the hotter finishing stage.

Roel searing the steak over the hot side of the Napoleon Kettle Pro
The reverse-seared steak gets a short direct-heat stage before the skillet finish.

Grill marks are not the whole crust

Roel briefly gives the steak grill marks, but says that the pattern alone is not the crust he wants. He places the cast iron skillet on the barbecue and finishes the sear there, using the pan’s contact with the meat to develop the outside.

This matters when comparing the results: the second steak is not simply a grill-only steak. It combines indirect cooking, a rest, a short spell over the coals and a skillet finish.

Roel discussing the sliced reverse-seared steak
Roel discusses the finish and interior of the reverse-seared steak.

What changed in the two steaks?

What Roel assesses Pan-seared steak Reverse-seared steak
Cooking sequence Crust and interior develop together in the pan, followed by basting and rest. Gentler indirect cooking first; the stronger sear comes later.
Interior in this test A visible grey edge around a pink centre. A more evenly pink interior with less grey at the edges.
Crust A well-developed pan crust and rendered fat edge. Grill marks followed by a skillet crust that Roel especially enjoys.
Attention required Frequent decisions about heat, turning, basting and when to stop. Temperature monitoring separates the gentler cooking phase from the final sear.

Why Roel prefers the reverse sear here

He likes the even interior and the final crust, and feels the process asks for less chef-style intuition. Separating the cook into stages makes it easier for him to follow what is happening.

That is his judgement from these two steaks, rather than a guarantee that one technique always produces a better result. The pan, steak thickness, fire and timing still affect either method.

The flavour comparison has another variable

Roel notes that the second steak sat with salt on it for longer because he cooked the pan version first. He thinks that contributed to its more pronounced flavour. The comparison therefore does not isolate the searing method as the sole reason for the taste difference.

His conclusion leaves room for both approaches: the classic pan method remains enjoyable, while the reverse sear gives him the control and finish he prefers in this session.

What to take into your next steak cook

  • Give the pan time to preheat and respond to what happens after the meat goes in.
  • Brown the striploin’s fat edge as well as its broad sides.
  • Reduce the heat when moving from searing to butter basting.
  • Use temperature readings to follow the centre instead of judging only by the crust.
  • For a reverse sear, treat the final browning as its own short stage.
  • When comparing methods, keep salting time and steak thickness in mind too.

Equipment used in the comparison

MAIN SPONSOR

Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle

The charcoal barbecue used for the reverse-sear portion of the comparison, with separate indirect and direct areas.

Explore the Napoleon Professional 22 Charcoal Kettle

ChefsTemp ProTemp 2 Plus

The wireless thermometer setup for following the steak through the indirect stage. The probe and app help Roel monitor the cook without repeatedly opening the lid.

Current partner offer: use code PITMASTERX for 25% off in the ChefsTemp shop.

Shop the ProTemp 2 Plus

PitmasterX hand-polished cast iron skillet

The skillet links both approaches: it handles the pan-cooked steak and provides the final contact sear for the barbecue version.

Shop the hand-polished skillet

Napoleon is the main sponsor of this video. ChefsTemp is the thermometer partner. The Napoleon and ChefsTemp links are sponsor links.

Watch the Ramsay method and reverse-sear test

Original video: I tried Gordon Ramsay’s VIRAL Steak Hack… Is It Still Perfect? · Published 28 May 2026.

Tested by Roel Westra

Roel is the cook behind PitmasterX. This article draws on his filmed steak comparison, its transcript and original video frames. The observations describe these cooks and his tasting impressions.

Continue with our cast iron steak crust guide or the Guga crust-first versus reverse-sear comparison.

Regresar al blog