Golden chicken wings on the Napoleon Apollo 22 during the PitmasterX velveting test

Does Velveting Make Better Chicken Wings? Our BBQ Test

Roel Westra

Can the tenderising trick used for Chinese stir-fried beef improve barbecue chicken wings? Roel tries a short velveting treatment, then cooks the wings on the Napoleon Apollo 22. The result tastes good. Whether the extra preparation earns its place is another question.

Is velveting chicken wings worth it?

In this PitmasterX test, Roel would skip the velveting next time. He enjoys the wings, but credits drying, seasoning, the hot cook with good airflow, and resting more than the baking-soda treatment. This is his tasting verdict from one filmed cook; the video does not show an untreated batch cooked alongside it.

Why try velveting on chicken wings?

The idea comes from Roel's earlier experience cooking meat in a wok on the barbecue. A tenderising preparation had made a noticeable difference to that meat, so he wanted to see whether it could help another cut.

Chicken wings make an interesting next test because there is more to judge than softness. The skin, the bite of the meat and the flavour all matter. A softer wing is not automatically a better wing.

The video starts with a clip from Wok God demonstrating a baking-soda treatment for beef. Roel then adapts the idea for wings. This article looks at that particular barbecue experiment and its outcome, rather than treating it as proof that every velveting method produces the same result.

Roel with baking soda, cornflour and rice vinegar for the chicken wing experiment
The experiment brings baking soda, cornflour, rice vinegar, water and seasoning into the preparation.

A short treatment, followed by drying

Roel combines the wings with cornflour, baking soda, rice vinegar, a little water and Chicken Seasoning. The mixture visibly bubbles. That reaction is an observation during preparation; it does not tell us how much the finished texture will improve.

He keeps the treatment to 10 minutes in the refrigerator. His concern is taking tenderness too far and ending up with an unpleasant, gummy texture. He describes this as a brief experiment, not an overnight marinade.

After removing the excess coating, he puts the wings on a rack and pats them dry. Then he seasons both sides again. This drying stage becomes one of the steps he singles out when explaining what he would keep for future cooks.

Chicken wings on a rack after drying and applying PitmasterX Chicken Seasoning
The wings are dried and seasoned again before going onto the Apollo.

What the Apollo setup contributes

Roel chooses the Napoleon Apollo 22 for the distance between the charcoal and the upper cooking grate. He removes the intervening trays and grates, leaving the wings above the fire on the top grate.

The setup matters when interpreting the result. These wings are being cooked in a tall charcoal smoker with a clear path from the coals to the upper grate. Copying only the clock time on a different barbecue does not reproduce that arrangement.

The Napoleon Apollo 22 smoker used in the PitmasterX chicken wing test
The Napoleon Apollo 22 provides the tall charcoal-to-grate arrangement used in this test.

The cooking conditions in the video

The smoker runs at about 160°C / 320°F. Roel gives the wings roughly 20 minutes on each side. At the core-temperature check, he reports 92°C / 198°F, slightly over that reading, and takes the wings off. They then rest for at least 10 minutes.

Those figures describe this filmed batch. Roel checks the meat itself instead of relying only on the elapsed time. The orange ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10 shown in the video makes that final spot check possible.

Roel checking the wings with an orange ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10, with 92 degrees Celsius shown on screen
The core-temperature check comes before the wings leave the smoker.

In his conclusion, Roel places particular emphasis on the hot airflow around the wings, the surface drying, and the rest. The equipment and preparation belong in the explanation alongside the tenderising treatment.

The result: tasty wings, no reason to add more work

The wings develop a browned exterior and Roel enjoys eating them. He notices some crunch, but also a softer texture and slightly sticky ends. His first reaction is positive about the food on the plate.

His final judgement is more selective: would he add the velveting process to his usual chicken-wing routine? No. He does not think the extra work has justified itself.

Roel tasting a chicken wing and assessing the result of the velveting experiment
The taste test produces a good wing, but Roel would leave out the velveting step next time.
What to take from this cook
Part of the test Roel's takeaway
Velveting treatment The finished wings taste good, but the extra work does not convince him.
Drying and seasoning These are central parts of the preparation he credits for the result.
Heat and airflow The Apollo setup is a major part of his explanation for the exterior and texture.
Temperature check and rest Both remain part of the cook, regardless of the tenderising experiment.

What this test does not establish

There is no simultaneous untreated control batch shown, no tenderness measurement, and no second treatment time tested. We can report Roel's experience and preference confidently. We cannot assign a measured improvement to baking soda or conclude that a longer treatment would be better.

That is a useful outcome in itself: a technique that impressed him in wok cooking did not earn a permanent place in his chicken-wing preparation.

Equipment and seasoning from the video

Main sponsor

Napoleon Apollo 22

The charcoal smoker used for this test. Roel uses its upper grate and the distance above the coals to cook the wings with the intervening trays removed.

View the Apollo 22 at Napoleon
Temperature check

ChefsTemp Finaltouch X10

The handheld thermometer shown during the core-temperature check. Its rotating probe helps you reach the meat between the bones when checking a wing.

Use code PITMASTERX for 25% off at ChefsTemp.

Shop the Finaltouch X10

Shop PitmasterX Chicken Seasoning to use the same seasoning Roel applies in this video.

Questions answered by this experiment

Did the wings taste good?

Yes. Roel enjoys the flavour and the finished wings. His reservation is whether velveting adds enough benefit to justify the preparation.

Would Roel velvet chicken wings again?

Not after this test. He would focus on drying, seasoning, the cooking setup and resting.

Does this prove that velveting never works?

No. The idea came from a positive wok-cooking experience. This video records his judgement of one short treatment on chicken wings.

Watch the full chicken-wing experiment

Watch the original video on YouTube

  1. 00:00 — Why try velveting chicken wings?
  2. 01:42 — Setting up the Apollo smoker
  3. 02:09 — Preparing the treatment
  4. 03:48 — Drying, seasoning and cooking
  5. 04:07 — Checking the core temperature
  6. 05:35 — Taste test and final verdict
Roel Westra · PitmasterX

Based on Roel's original filmed chicken-wing experiment. Photographs are frames from the video. The publication timestamp matches the original YouTube upload.

Explore another PitmasterX experiment: dry-aged vs wet-aged steak.

Back to blog