Roel Westra compares a thick charcoal-grilled burger with a double smash burger.

Smash Burger vs Classic Burger: Our Side-by-Side Test

Roel Westra
Roel Westra compares a thick charcoal-grilled burger with a double smash burger.
Two burger styles, one tasting: a thick charcoal-grilled burger and a double smash burger.

Why does a smash burger taste so different from a thick burger when both start with the same kind of beef? I put a double smash burger from a flat-top griddle next to a thick charcoal-grilled burger to find out what mattered most: the crust, the juicy centre or the way the toppings changed each bite.

Seasonings featured in this comparison

The PitmasterX flavours in this test

PitmasterX Texas Seasoning

PitmasterX Texas Seasoning

Texas Seasoning featured on both styles of beef patty in the video.

Shop Texas Seasoning
PitmasterX Beef Seasoning

PitmasterX Beef Seasoning

Beef Seasoning featured in the sauces that accompanied both burgers in the tasting.

Shop Beef Seasoning

Two burger styles, two different priorities

The starting beef had an approximately 80/20 lean-to-fat ratio for both burgers. What changed was its shape and the way it met the heat. The smash burger had two thin patties cooked on a stainless-steel griddle over gas. The classic burger had one thick patty cooked on the Napoleon Charcoal Pro.

A thin patty gives a large share of each bite to the browned exterior. A thick patty leaves more of the bite to the interior. In this comparison, those two structures produced very different eating experiences.

Our observations from this cook and tasting
What changed? Double smash burger Thick classic burger
Heat contact Broad contact with a solid griddle Contact with grill bars over charcoal
Structure Two thin patties with more crust in each bite One thick patty with a more substantial centre
Texture Crisp edges and pronounced crunch A softer, noticeably juicier bite
Flavour balance Cheese, sauces and pickles stood out Beef flavour came through more clearly
My reason to choose it The combination of crust, crunch and toppings The juicy, beef-led eating experience

Why the smash burger developed so much crust

The defining feature was contact with the cooking surface. Pressing the beef against a solid plate created a broad, thin patty. Much of its underside touched hot metal at once, giving the browned surface a prominent role.

The edges were particularly important to the texture. They were thin enough for the crust to dominate the bite. The double stack added another layer of that browned exterior, with melted cheese between the patties.

Two browned smash burger patties with melted cheddar on the griddle.
Thin patties on a solid plate: the browned surfaces and edges shaped the smash burger’s texture.

A solid griddle changes what the grill can do. Open grates leave gaps between the bars; the plate provides continuous support for the flattened beef. Here, the cooking surface was part of the technique, rather than simply a different place to put the same burger.

The result was the crunchiest burger of the two. That describes this cook, rather than proving that every smash burger will have the same texture.

Why the thick burger felt juicier

The thick burger had a different balance between exterior and centre. There was still a grilled surface, but much more of each bite came from the interior. That gave the beef a fuller, softer presence alongside the cheese and toppings.

A thick beef burger patty cooking on the Napoleon charcoal grill.
The thick beef patty goes directly onto the charcoal grill grates.

With a thicker patty, the outside and centre develop at different rates. The closed lid helped heat the whole burger while the grates and charcoal acted on its exterior. The crust alone could not tell me what was happening in the middle, so I checked it with a ChefsTemp thermometer.

My chosen core temperature for the thick burger in this filmed test was 52°C. That finished doneness is part of the result, alongside the thickness and charcoal setup.

The bitten thick burger showing the pink centre from the filmed taste test.
Inside the thick burger from our filmed taste test.

Some of the juices ran into the bun during the tasting. Even so, the thick burger was noticeably juicier to me than the double smash burger. This was a sensory observation; we did not measure moisture loss or compare the burgers by weight after cooking.

The toppings changed which flavours stood out

Both burgers had cheese, pickles and the same two styles of sauce. Their role in the bite was different. On the smash burger, I noticed the toppings strongly alongside the crisp beef. The sharpness of the pickles and the sweet, smoky sauce were a large part of its appeal.

On the thick burger, the beef came forward more clearly and the sauces felt less dominant. That does not prove that thicker beef contains more flavour. It shows how the balance between meat, browned surface and toppings can change what you notice first.

The cheese also worked differently in the two formats: between thin patties it became part of a layered texture; on the thick burger there was a larger piece of beef beneath it. The complete bite mattered more than judging any one component on its own.

The side-by-side taste test

Double smash: the most crunch and the boldest toppings

I tasted the double smash burger first. The crust was its strongest feature: crisp, crunchy and immediately noticeable. The cheese and condiments added plenty of flavour around it. That combination of texture and toppings was its appeal.

Thick classic: the juicier, more beef-led bite

The thick burger brought the beef to the centre of the experience. Its juiciness was the clearest difference, and its flavour stood out more distinctly against the sauces. That was what I preferred with the two burgers next to each other.

My winner was the thick burger. The double smash still delivered something the thick burger did not: that much crisp crust in every bite. My preference does not make one style the right answer for everyone.

What this comparison tells us

Patty shape and cooking surface change the character of a burger. A flat, thin patty puts more emphasis on crust. A thick patty puts more emphasis on the centre. Cheese and toppings then interact with those textures.

We compared two complete styles. Thickness, cooking surface and finished doneness all differed. The tasting therefore cannot isolate which single factor caused the difference in juiciness, or prove that one type of grill always makes the better burger.

What it does offer is a useful choice: the smash burger for crisp edges and layered toppings, or the thick burger for the juicy, beef-led bite that won me over in this test.

Equipment behind the comparison

These links take you to the relevant brands and products. Napoleon and ChefsTemp sponsor this episode; the seasonings are from our own PitmasterX range.

Main sponsor · Napoleon

Gas grill with a flat-top griddle

The stainless-steel insert turned the Napoleon gas grill into a continuous cooking surface. Broad contact with the beef was central to the smash burger’s crust.

Explore the Napoleon Prestige range

View Napoleon griddle inserts and model compatibility.

Napoleon Charcoal Pro

The thick burger was cooked on the Napoleon Charcoal Pro. Its grates and lid supported a different approach: grilling the exterior over charcoal while heat also reached the thicker centre.

View the Napoleon Charcoal Pro

Temperature checks · ChefsTemp

ChefsTemp instant-read thermometer

The thermometer gave me a reading from inside the thick patty, beyond what its crust could show. For a compact instant-read option, explore the ChefsTemp Pocket Pro.

Save 25% with code PITMASTERX
Enter the code at ChefsTemp checkout.

Shop the ChefsTemp Pocket Pro

Limited-time offer, expected until mid-January 2027. ChefsTemp’s current terms apply; check the final discount at checkout.

Watch the full burger comparison

Jump to the grill setups, techniques and tasting:

Questions about the comparison

Why did the smash burger have more crunch?

The thin patties had broad contact with a solid hot plate. Their browned surfaces and crisp edges made up a larger share of each bite, and the double stack combined two of those patties.

Are thick burgers always juicier?

Our thick burger was juicier in this tasting. Thickness, cooking surface and finished doneness all differed, so this one comparison cannot establish a universal rule.

Why was the beef flavour clearer in the thick burger?

That was Roel’s tasting impression. The thick burger had a larger interior in each bite, and the toppings felt less dominant. In the smash burger, the crust, cheese and condiments were more prominent together.

Did charcoal beat the gas griddle?

The test compared two burger styles rather than two fuels under identical conditions. Roel preferred the thick charcoal-grilled burger, but the differences cannot be attributed to the fuel alone.

Which burger did Roel prefer?

The thick classic burger, because of its juiciness and clearer beef flavour. He still enjoyed the smash burger for its crunch and the way the toppings stood out.

Back to blog