Smoked Chuck Steak: 48 vs 72 Hours in the Borniak
Roel WestraCan a smoker give chuck steak the tenderness people normally chase with sous vide? I seasoned the beef, gave it a beechwood smoke, then wrapped it with beef tallow for a very long, low-temperature cook in the Borniak. The real question became: what changes between 48 and 72 hours?
The result: at the 48-hour check, the beef was soft but still held together for slicing. At 72 hours, it separated much more easily into strands. For the pull-apart texture I wanted, the longer cook was the winner.
Start with chuck, then build the bark
These steaks came from a chuck roast: beef from the shoulder that gives you plenty of flavour, but needs a different approach from a quick-grilling steak. This experiment was about getting that cut tender while keeping the smoke and seasoned crust that make barbecue worth the wait.
I set the Borniak to 120°C / 248°F, loaded beechwood chips and smoked the seasoned steaks for approximately three hours. Before moving on, I wanted a dark, developed surface. That first stage gives the meat its barbecue character; the following stage is all about time and texture.

Bring the heat down before wrapping
Once the bark had developed, I removed the steaks and lowered the smoker temperature. Opening the door helped release the heat left over from the smoking stage. Simply changing the setting does not make a hot cooking chamber cool down immediately.
The low-temperature setting in my final recap is 65°C / 149°F. Each steak went onto aluminium foil with a slice of beef tallow, then into a tight parcel. The tallow adds richness, while the foil keeps the rendered fat and cooking juices close to the meat.
With the smoker cooled down, the wrapped beef went back inside. From here, the goal was a steady, gentle cook. For an experiment this long, checking the actual cooking temperature matters more than trusting the number on a control panel.

48 hours vs 72 hours: the difference is texture
Opening the first parcel at the 48-hour check revealed plenty of juices. The knife passed through the meat easily, but the fibres still held together. It was soft beef that could be sliced, with some structure left in every piece.
That was already a good result, but I wanted to see what another day would do. At the 72-hour check, the meat gave way much more readily. A gentle squeeze and a pull with my hands separated it into strands. That is the texture that made the longer cook worthwhile for me.
| Stage | What I looked for | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Initial smoke | About 3 hours at 120°C / 248°F | Beechwood smoke and a dark bark before wrapping |
| 48-hour check | Softness with some structure | Easy to slice; fibres still held together |
| 72-hour check | More complete breakdown | Beef pulled apart much more easily by hand |

The takeaway is to decide what you want to serve. Soft slices and pull-apart beef are two different results. In this cook, 48 hours gave me the first; 72 hours took the texture further.

Does this replace sous vide?
It gives me another way to chase long-cooked tenderness, with smoke already built into the meat. There is no water bath or vacuum bag in this method: it is foil-wrapped beef in a smoker. The video explores that approach; it does not run a controlled comparison against a separate sous-vide batch.
What I like is the combination. I can build bark first, then use the same cooker for the long finish. An oven that can accurately maintain the required low temperature is another possibility discussed in the video, although occupying the kitchen oven for days is not particularly convenient.
If you enjoy exploring less expensive beef cuts, also read our chuck roll vs brisket comparison.
Watch the complete experiment
Equipment and seasoning
- Borniak 150: the smoker for the initial beechwood smoke and the long finish. Explore the Borniak 150.
- ChefsTemp ProTemp S2: keeping track of actual temperatures is especially useful during a long cook. Visit the ChefsTemp shop. Use code PITMASTERX for 25% off.
- PitmasterX Beef Seasoning: applied before smoking. Shop Beef Seasoning.
Made possible by Borniak. ChefsTemp is a PitmasterX partner. PitmasterX Beef Seasoning is our own product.
