Ribeye steak with dark diamond grill marks held above the cutting board

Karen’s Competition Steak Method: A Ribeye Test on the Kettle

Roel Westra

A competition steak has to make an impression in a single bite. I put Karen’s approach to the test on the Napoleon kettle: a carefully selected ribeye, a short marinade, two layers of seasoning and a very deliberate set of grill marks. The result changed how I think about cooking steak for a judge.

Ribeye steak with dark diamond grill marks held above the cutting board
Karen’s Competition Steak Method: A Ribeye Test on the Kettle

Start with the right part of the ribeye

The first decision happens at the butcher’s block. In the video, I look for a ribeye from the chuck end with three distinct sections of muscle. Those different textures and the fat between them give the front edge of the steak a particularly rich bite. A large central eye alone is not the only thing to look for.

For this cook I cut the steak roughly one and a half finger widths thick, rather than the much thicker steaks I often grill at home. I trim the outside carefully, removing tough surface tissue and excess fat. Toothpicks help hold the sections together, while butcher’s twine keeps the steak round. The twine should support the shape without squeezing the meat tightly.

A short marinade, then two layers of seasoning

Karen’s competition approach includes a commercial marinade. For my version, I build a savoury mixture with beef broth, garlic, paprika, turmeric, black and white pepper, a little dried glucose syrup and MSG. This is my adaptation of the approach shown in the episode, rather than a claim to reproduce Karen’s exact competition formula.

The toothpicks quickly expose a practical problem: they puncture the bag. A shallow container works much better. The steak gets around 20 minutes on each side, followed by a thorough pat dry.

Next come PitmasterX Beef Seasoning and Texas BBQ Seasoning, layered over both sides. I leave them for about 10 minutes before grilling. This is a deliberately intense flavour build. You can understand the logic when the aim is one memorable mouthful.

Roel presenting his competition-style steak at the outdoor cooking table
Careful trimming, shaping and seasoning make this a more involved cook than an everyday steak.

Grill marks need their own plan

I light the Napoleon kettle with charcoal and briquettes and use a straight-ridged grilling panel for the diamond pattern. A little neutral oil helps prepare the surface. The first contact is about 90 seconds under a weight, but the marks develop darker than I intended. That is the useful lesson: the clock is only a guide when the cooking surface is this hot.

For the next set of lines, I turn the steak onto a fresh part of the grate and shorten the contact to around a minute. The other side also needs a clean, lightly oiled area. A spatula can shield an exposed edge of fat from excessive direct contact while the face of the steak sears.

Beautiful marks do not tell you what is happening in the centre. After the initial sear, my ChefsTemp X10 shows only about 36°C / 97°F. There is still a substantial amount of cooking to do.

Finish gently without adding unwanted marks

The steak moves away from the direct heat onto a raised, initially cold rack. That lets the centre continue warming without burning another pattern into the surface. My intended finishing temperature for this cook is around 57°C / 135°F.

This stage takes patience. Even after another 15 minutes, the centre is only around 46°C / 115°F. The distance from the coals and the heat in the kettle matter more than a fixed steak timetable. I check with the X10, brush on warm butter near the end and remove the steak a little before the intended finishing temperature so it can rest.

Before slicing, remove the twine and every toothpick. Then present the steak with the richest, multi-muscle edge facing the person taking the first bite.

Roel tasting the ribeye cooked using Karen’s competition approach
The tasting focuses on tenderness, juiciness and the concentration of flavour in a small bite.

What I learned from the tasting

The finished steak is soft, juicy and packed with savoury flavour. The marinade and the two seasonings make a noticeable difference to the intensity of a small bite. I can see why this approach makes sense in a competition setting.

It also takes more organisation than I expected. The trimming, shaping, marinating, grate management and careful finish all add work. For a relaxed dinner I may still choose a simpler steak. For learning how much thought can go into one judged bite, this cook is an excellent exercise.

This episode is my kitchen test and tasting of the method; it does not include an official competition score. The most useful takeaway is to separate your decisions: choose the bite you want, build the flavour, create the surface, and finish the centre with a thermometer.

Equipment

Use code PITMASTERX for 25% off at ChefsTemp.

Watch the cook

Watch on YouTube

In this video

By Roel Westra — PitmasterX. Based on the original cook shown in the video.

Terug naar blog