Grilled Hanger Steak with Spicy Chili Mayonnaise
Roel WestraHanger steak gives you a deep beef flavour, a great crust and a tender bite when you trim and slice it properly. Here I grill it on the Napoleon Phantom 500 and serve it with a creamy chili mayonnaise made with Beef Seasoning, sriracha and green chili.

The steak quantity, four servings and timings are practical estimates. Sauce quantities follow the video. Optional overnight chilling for the mayonnaise is additional.
The tendon is the first thing to remove
Hanger steak is also known as butcher’s steak. The thick seam running down its middle needs attention before cooking. Separate the two muscles along that seam, then remove the tough tendon and silver skin. You will have two manageable pieces that grill quickly.

Make the sauce ahead if you can
The mayonnaise starts creamy and tangy, followed by a gentle chili kick. White wine vinegar cuts through its richness, while sugar balances the acidity. Half of the green chili goes into the sauce; the other half provides a fresh garnish.
You can serve it straight away, as I do in the video, or leave it covered in the fridge overnight. Taste before adding more sriracha, since the heat of fresh chilies varies.

A quick sear suits the hanger steak
The ribeye comparison in the video starts with a reverse sear. The thinner hanger steak goes straight over direct heat. I use the compatible Napoleon charcoal tray for that part of the cook, giving the meat a browned surface while keeping an eye on the centre.
The video’s price comparison reflects the steaks bought for that episode. Prices will vary, but the useful comparison is how much trimmed, enjoyable meat you get from each cut.

Cut across the visible fibres
Rest the steak, then look closely at the grain. Slicing across those fibres makes a noticeable difference to the bite. Add a little mayonnaise to each slice, and keep the rest on the table for anyone who wants more.
Ingredients
Steak
- 800 g / 1.75 lb trimmed hanger steak, divided along the central tendon
- Salt, to taste
Spicy chili mayonnaise
- 250 ml / 1 cup mayonnaise
- 2 tbsp white wine vinegar
- 1 tbsp sugar
- 1 tbsp PitmasterX Beef Seasoning
- 2 tsp sriracha
- 1 mild green chili pepper, divided
- A pinch of chili powder
- A pinch of chili flakes
How to make it
- Mix the chili mayonnaiseHalve the green chili and remove the seeds. Finely chop half and reserve the rest for garnish. Mix the mayonnaise, vinegar, sugar, Beef Seasoning, sriracha, chopped chili, chili powder and chili flakes. Taste and adjust the heat. Cover and refrigerate while you prepare the steak; make it the day before for a more developed flavour.
- Trim the hanger steakFollow the thick tendon through the middle of the hanger steak with a sharp knife. Divide the steak into its two long muscles and remove the tendon and remaining silver skin. Season the meat with salt.
- Prepare the Phantom 500Set up the Napoleon Phantom 500 with a direct grilling area and a cooler area to move the steak to if needed. The video uses the compatible Napoleon charcoal tray for the sear. If using that accessory, install and light it according to Napoleon’s instructions and turn off the gas burners once the charcoal is established.
- Grill and monitorGrill the trimmed hanger steak over direct heat, turning to develop an even crust. Use the ChefsTemp S2 ProTemp to follow the internal temperature, keeping the probe within its specified limits. Move the steak away from flare-ups. Allow roughly 8–12 minutes, depending on thickness and heat.
- Rest before the final targetThe video removes the hanger steak at about 47°C / 117°F, aiming for 52–54°C / 126–129°F after resting. Treat that as the result of this cook: carryover varies with thickness and heat. Rest on a board for approximately 5–10 minutes and check the actual result against your preferred doneness.
- Slice and serveLook at the direction of the fibres in each piece and slice across the grain. Spoon the chili mayonnaise over the steak or serve it alongside. Garnish with the reserved green chili and a few chili flakes if you like.
Equipment
- Napoleon Phantom 500.
- ChefsTemp S2 ProTemp.
- A sharp knife, chopping board, mixing bowl and grill tongs.
- Optional compatible Napoleon charcoal tray, fitted and used according to its manual.
Use code PITMASTERX for 25% off at ChefsTemp.
Watch the video
In this video
- 00:00 — Intro: The High Cost of the Ribeye King
- 00:53 — Prepping the Ribeye: Reverse Sear & Smoked Salt
- 01:25 — Grill Setup: Creating Direct & Indirect Zones
- 01:51 — The Challenger: Why Hanger Steak is Half the Price
- 02:23 — Butchery 101: Removing the Hanger Steak Tendon
- 03:23 — Recipe: Homemade Zesty Chili Mayonnaise
- 05:00 — The Flip: Converting Gas to Charcoal for the Sear
- 05:42 — The Waste Test: How Much Ribeye Do You Actually Eat?
- 06:54 — Grilling the Hanger Steak: Intramuscular Fat & High Heat
- 07:45 — The Secret to Tenderness: Slicing Against the Grain
- 08:25 — Final Comparison: Taste, Value, and Plating
